Dark Star Posted Tuesday at 02:51 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 02:51 PM 38 minutes ago, mgerb said: A likely factor: besides imparting sensible heat to the lower atmosphere, the lakes also impart moisture. Slightly increased boundary layer moisture->higher dew points (and perhaps more clouds)->warmer TMINs. This definitely happens, especially closer to the Great Lakes. Down here, to a much lower degree. Unquantifiable, therefore, not (officially) a factor here. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mgerb Posted Tuesday at 03:07 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:07 PM 19 minutes ago, Dark Star said: Unquantifiable, therefore, not (officially) a factor here. OK....don't know what you mean. It is quantifiable. Look at a DP map during the winter upwind vs downwind of the Great Lakes. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
psv88 Posted Tuesday at 03:33 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:33 PM Highs are going to be in the mid 40s for much of this week. Winter ended real fast apparently. No cold in sight 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
jm1220 Posted Tuesday at 03:40 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:40 PM 5 minutes ago, psv88 said: Highs are going to be in the mid 40s for much of this week. Winter ended real fast apparently. No cold in sight When we lose the cross polar source region and go back to modified polar, no surprise the temp forecasts go up as a result. 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dark Star Posted Tuesday at 03:54 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:54 PM 44 minutes ago, mgerb said: OK....don't know what you mean. It is quantifiable. Look at a DP map during the winter upwind vs downwind of the Great Lakes. and you can quantify the effect on NYC and it takes in account the effects of downsloping, cloud cover, snow cover, and all other variables? Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dark Star Posted Tuesday at 03:56 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 03:56 PM 1 hour ago, bluewave said: Yeah, the much warmer minimum temperature departures than the maximums across the Northeast this month were very obvious. Ever hear that high winds impedes radiational cooling? If you can show me the calculations, then maybe it can be considered. Of course you would have to taken in heating due to downsloping, etc... Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mgerb Posted Tuesday at 04:25 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:25 PM 28 minutes ago, Dark Star said: and you can quantify the effect on NYC and it takes in account the effects of downsloping, cloud cover, snow cover, and all other variables? Never said that. I'm referring to air mass modification vis-à-vis the transport of polar air masses over the Great Lakes, particularly just downwind. The effect is reduced the further you travel from the lakes, but it's not zero. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bluewave Posted Tuesday at 04:28 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:28 PM 41 minutes ago, Dark Star said: Ever hear that high winds impedes radiational cooling? If you can show me the calculations, then maybe it can be considered. Of course you would have to taken in heating due to downsloping, etc... High winds plus the record January cloud cover coming off the lakes both worked in tandem to warm the minimum departures. So it’s no surprise that the brief radiational cooling around the 22nd occurred during a relaxation of the flow over the Lakes in conjunction with the snow cover. It’s also true that the stronger winds across the Great Lakes picked up clouds and downsloped into JFK adding enough warmth so JFK only dropped to 13° which was a little warmer than the 12 in December. This was only the 3rd such occurrence of the January minimum not exceeding the December minimum at JFK in 24 years. So this January can make for an interesting study of the highly anomalous temperature pattern in the Northeast relative to areas further south. Northern Maine going +5 with West Virginia at -10 never occurred before in modern times during January. Add in the warmest year on record in Canada and latest freeze-up on Hudson Bay along with record Great Lakes warmth to start the season. And we can’t forget the near record 500 mb vortex east of New England for any January acting has a huge gyre causing the flow to travel down from the Hudson Bay and across the Great Lakes. The rapidly warming climate especially since mid 2023 continues to set records. Monthly Lowest Min Temperature for New York-Kennedy Airport Area, NY (ThreadEx)Click column heading to sort ascending, click again to sort descending. 2024-2025 12 13 12 2023-2024 25 18 18 2022-2023 7 29 7 2021-2022 24 9 9 2020-2021 18 15 15 2019-2020 17 19 17 2018-2019 24 3 3 2017-2018 9 4 4 2016-2017 19 13 13 2015-2016 34 12 12 2014-2015 26 8 8 2013-2014 20 3 3 2012-2013 28 12 12 2011-2012 21 13 13 2010-2011 19 6 6 2009-2010 16 14 14 2008-2009 14 7 7 2007-2008 20 14 14 2006-2007 19 9 9 2005-2006 15 14 14 2004-2005 12 6 6 2003-2004 21 1 1 2002-2003 18 7 7 2001-2002 21 22 21 2000-2001 14 15 14 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LibertyBell Posted Tuesday at 04:35 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:35 PM 38 minutes ago, Dark Star said: Ever hear that high winds impedes radiational cooling? If you can show me the calculations, then maybe it can be considered. Of course you would have to taken in heating due to downsloping, etc... wind direction might have something to do with it too. If we had more of a northerly wind rather than a westerly wind, we would have much less downsloping and a direct shot of arctic air. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bluewave Posted Tuesday at 04:41 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 04:41 PM 19 minutes ago, LibertyBell said: wind direction might have something to do with it too. If we had more of a northerly wind rather than a westerly wind, we would have much less downsloping and a direct shot of arctic air. It’s why areas most east of the Hudson this month couldn’t come anywhere close the lows from early February 2023 with that impressive northerly flow which avoided the Great Lakes. 1 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
steve392 Posted Tuesday at 05:55 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 05:55 PM Winds are absolutely howling up here in Mahwah. Looks like its snowing but its all the dried up rock salt getting blown all over. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dark Star Posted Tuesday at 06:12 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 06:12 PM 1 hour ago, mgerb said: Never said that. I'm referring to air mass modification vis-à-vis the transport of polar air masses over the Great Lakes, particularly just downwind. The effect is reduced the further you travel from the lakes, but it's not zero. I will daresay less than 1 degree, and a lot less than winds reducing the effect of overnight radiational cooling, downsloping, lack of snow cover. Until someone can quantify it for NYC, it is a non item. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mgerb Posted Tuesday at 06:32 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 06:32 PM 10 minutes ago, Dark Star said: I will daresay less than 1 degree, and a lot less than winds reducing the effect of overnight radiational cooling, downsloping, lack of snow cover. Until someone can quantify it for NYC, it is a non item. But there IS research on this topic that quantifies climate with/without the Great Lakes. For example, see the paper below. Doesn't answer how much the GLs affect NYC-area climate specifically (falls just outside the "Great Lakes Basin" domain), but it's apparent that the large thermal inertia of the GLs has a notable effect on regional climate. That wouldn't completely disappear outside the domain, but no doubt it's reduced compared to areas closer to the lakes. https://journals.ametsoc.org/view/journals/clim/26/3/jcli-d-12-00140.1.pdf 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
psv88 Posted Tuesday at 06:33 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 06:33 PM 19 minutes ago, Dark Star said: I will daresay less than 1 degree, and a lot less than winds reducing the effect of overnight radiational cooling, downsloping, lack of snow cover. Until someone can quantify it for NYC, it is a non item. Even if there was an impact why would it only impact night time temps and not day time? That’s what I’m not getting…the lakes only impact the temps at night? 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
mgerb Posted Tuesday at 06:44 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 06:44 PM 1 minute ago, psv88 said: Even if there was an impact why would it only impact night time temps and not day time? That’s what I’m not getting…the lakes only impact the temps at night? It really would affect both, but would expect to see it more at night when increased moisture and (perhaps) clouds could reduce overnight cooling. During the day, temps are largely driven by solar insolation, and the presence or lack of can overtake other factors. Just spitballing though; it's all very complicated and depends on many factors. Point is, the GLs contain huge thermal inertia that greatly affects climate within the 50-100 miles downwind. Less clear as you get down towards our area and I'd agree that any effect is likely very subtle. 4 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Allsnow Posted Tuesday at 08:25 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 08:25 PM 1 hour ago, mgerb said: It really would affect both, but would expect to see it more at night when increased moisture and (perhaps) clouds could reduce overnight cooling. During the day, temps are largely driven by solar insolation, and the presence or lack of can overtake other factors. Just spitballing though; it's all very complicated and depends on many factors. Point is, the GLs contain huge thermal inertia that greatly affects climate within the 50-100 miles downwind. Less clear as you get down towards our area and I'd agree that any effect is likely very subtle. Thank you Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
donsutherland1 Posted Tuesday at 10:03 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 10:03 PM Temperatures rose into the 40s across the Middle Atlantic Region today. Baltimore and Washington, DC topped out at 50° and 54° respectively. The mild weather will likely continue through tomorrow before another cold front arrives. The front could be accompanied by some snow flurries. Behind the front, it will turn briefly colder, but the coldest anomalies will occur across Upstate New York and New England. The cold won't rival that of last week. Although the cold air mass will originate in northern Russia, that region has been experienccing near record and record warmth. As a result, the air mass will not be exceptionally cold when it reaches eastern North America. January will likely end with a rebound in temperatures and rain developing across the Middle Atlantic region. New York City and Philadelphia could pick up 0.50" or more. Upstate New York State and northern New England could see snow and ice. The AO is now positive and is expected to remain predominantly positive through at least the first week of February. As a result, prospects for a 6" or above snowstorm in the New York City area will be limited. Since 1950, just 2 of 19 (11%) of storms with an AO of +2.000 or above during January 15-February 15 saw 6" or more of snow in New York City. Opportunities for a 6" or above snowstorm could persist for parts of southern New England, including Boston, through the first week of February. The ENSO Region 1+2 anomaly was -0.4°C and the Region 3.4 anomaly was -0.9°C for the week centered around January 22. For the past six weeks, the ENSO Region 1+2 anomaly has averaged -0.08°C and the ENSO Region 3.4 anomaly has averaged -0.80°C. La Niña conditions are underway and will likely persist into the start of spring. The SOI was +14.28 today. The preliminary Arctic Oscillation (AO) was +1.847 today. Based on sensitivity analysis applied to the latest guidance, there is an implied near 100% probability that New York City will have a colder than normal January (1991-2020 normal). January will likely finish with a mean temperature near 30.7° (3.2° below normal). 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bluewave Posted Tuesday at 10:17 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 10:17 PM Tomorrow looks like the kind of westerly flow day that high temperatures and winds can beat expectations with the very steep lapse rates and deep mixed layer. A 45-50 day for temps and wind gusts. This has been the strongest westerly flow January of the 2020s. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Brian5671 Posted Tuesday at 11:04 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 11:04 PM Should have been a wind advisory for most of the areas today with gusts to 45-50 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gravitylover Posted Tuesday at 11:58 PM Share Posted Tuesday at 11:58 PM 1 hour ago, bluewave said: Tomorrow looks like the kind of westerly flow day that high temperatures and winds can beat expectations with the very steep lapse rates and deep mixed layer. A 45-50 day for temps and wind gusts. This has been the strongest westerly flow January of the 2020s. After an anamolously long period of easterlies. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SACRUS Posted yesterday at 03:36 AM Share Posted yesterday at 03:36 AM Up to 44 today. Snow 75% gone. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SACRUS Posted yesterday at 03:45 AM Share Posted yesterday at 03:45 AM Records: Highs: EWR: 62 (2002) NYC: 66 (1916) LGA: 60 (2002) JFK: 60 (2002) Lows: EWR: -4 (1935) NYC: -2 (1925) LGA: 7 (2005) JFK: 6 (2005) Historical: 1887: Snowflakes "as large as milk pans" fell at Fort Keogh of Montana. The flakes, which were said to measure 15 inches across and 8 inches thick, hold the unofficial size record! 1922 - The "Knickerbocker" storm immobilized the city of Washington D.C. The storm produced 28 inches of snow in 32 hours, and the heavy snow caused the roof of the Knickerbocker movie theatre to collapse killing 96 persons. (David Ludlum) 1963 - The low of -34 degrees at Cynthiana, KY, equalled the state record established just four days earlier at Bonnieville. (The Weather Channel) 1969: Heavy rains of tropical origin that began on 1/18 ended on this day. As much as 50 inches of rain fell at 7,700 feet. 31 inches of rain fell on the south slopes of Mt. San Gorgonio, 15.5 inches at San Jacinto Peak, around ten inches at Banning, less than one inch from Indio southeast. 91 were reported dead from flooding and mudslides all over California and state-wide. 1977: The Blizzard of '77 was one of the worst winter storms to hit southern Ontario and upstate New York. With the rapid onset of the storm, about 2,000 students in the Niagara region were stranded overnight in schools. 1986: The Space Shuttle Challenger broke apart at 11:39 am EST, 73 seconds after liftoff from the Kennedy Space Center at Cape Canaveral, Florida, on a frigid morning. Starting in the 20s, the ground temperature at liftoff was 36 degrees. Morton Thiokol recommended not launching if the liftoff temperature was below 53 degrees. The cold was blamed for causing the O-rings on the Shuttle's external booster to fail, leading to the explosion. Low-level wind shear also played a factor. 1987 - A storm moving out of the Central Rockies into the Northern Plains Region produced up to a foot of snow in the Colorado Rockies, and wind gusts to 99 mph at Boulder CO. High winds in Colorado caused 5.6 million dollars damage. (National Weather Summary) (Storm Data) 1988 - Barometric pressure readings of 30.55 inches at Miami FL, 30.66 inches at Tampa FL, and 30.72 inches at Apalachicola FL were all-time record high readings for those locations. (National Weather Summary) 1989 - Nome, AK, reported an all-time record low reading of 54 degrees below zero, and the temperature at Fairwell AK dipped to 69 degrees below zero. Deadhorse AK reported a morning low of 49 degrees below zero, and with a wind chill reading of 114 degrees below zero. In the Lower Forty-eight States, a winter storm over Colorado produced up to 15 inches of snow around Denver. (National Weather Summary) (Storm Data) 1990 - Strong and gusty winds prevailed across the northwestern U.S., and heavy snow continued over the mountains of Washington State and Oregon. In Idaho, Mullan received seven inches of snow, and winds gusted to 65 mph southeast of Burley. Heavy rain soaked coastal sections of western Oregon. Rainfall totals of 1.20 inches at Portland and 1.57 inches at Eugene were records for the date. Winds in Oregon gusting to 60 mph downed power lines in Umatilla County knocking out power to more than 13,000 homes, just prior to the kick-off of the "Super Bowl" game. (National Weather Summary) (Storm Data) 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
SACRUS Posted yesterday at 03:47 AM Share Posted yesterday at 03:47 AM NYC Jan 28, 2022 - 8.3 inches of snowfall 2 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LibertyBell Posted yesterday at 05:36 AM Share Posted yesterday at 05:36 AM 7 hours ago, bluewave said: Tomorrow looks like the kind of westerly flow day that high temperatures and winds can beat expectations with the very steep lapse rates and deep mixed layer. A 45-50 day for temps and wind gusts. This has been the strongest westerly flow January of the 2020s. I hope this is a sign for a lot of westerly flow for the summer We could use another summer that's hot and not humid a la 1966 and 2010. 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
weathermedic Posted 21 hours ago Share Posted 21 hours ago Wind advisory for the entire area today Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bluewave Posted 17 hours ago Share Posted 17 hours ago 12 hours ago, gravitylover said: After an anamolously long period of easterlies. These were some of the strongest westerlies since Janaury 1977. So this used to be a much colder pattern. Janaury 1977 was nearly 10° colder on average around the area than this month was. But at least we can brag that we got some version of the Jan 77 analog to repeat in a much warmer fashion. 1 1 Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Dark Star Posted 17 hours ago Share Posted 17 hours ago 20 hours ago, bluewave said: High winds plus the record January cloud cover coming off the lakes both worked in tandem to warm the minimum departures. So it’s no surprise that the brief radiational cooling around the 22nd occurred during a relaxation of the flow over the Lakes in conjunction with the snow cover. It’s also true that the stronger winds across the Great Lakes picked up clouds and downsloped into JFK adding enough warmth so JFK only dropped to 13° which was a little warmer than the 12 in December. This was only the 3rd such occurrence of the January minimum not exceeding the December minimum at JFK in 24 years. So this January can make for an interesting study of the highly anomalous temperature pattern in the Northeast relative to areas further south. Northern Maine going +5 with West Virginia at -10 never occurred before in modern times during January. Add in the warmest year on record in Canada and latest freeze-up on Hudson Bay along with record Great Lakes warmth to start the season. And we can’t forget the near record 500 mb vortex east of New England for any January acting has a huge gyre causing the flow to travel down from the Hudson Bay and across the Great Lakes. The rapidly warming climate especially since mid 2023 continues to set records. Monthly Lowest Min Temperature for New York-Kennedy Airport Area, NY (ThreadEx)Click column heading to sort ascending, click again to sort descending. 2024-2025 12 13 12 2023-2024 25 18 18 2022-2023 7 29 7 2021-2022 24 9 9 2020-2021 18 15 15 2019-2020 17 19 17 2018-2019 24 3 3 2017-2018 9 4 4 2016-2017 19 13 13 2015-2016 34 12 12 2014-2015 26 8 8 2013-2014 20 3 3 2012-2013 28 12 12 2011-2012 21 13 13 2010-2011 19 6 6 2009-2010 16 14 14 2008-2009 14 7 7 2007-2008 20 14 14 2006-2007 19 9 9 2005-2006 15 14 14 2004-2005 12 6 6 2003-2004 21 1 1 2002-2003 18 7 7 2001-2002 21 22 21 2000-2001 14 15 14 That doesn't prove anything. Radiational cooling is always minimized with stronger winds, and is at it s peak with no winds. This theory is going nowhere without true modeling. While there may be a minute difference in warming from the unfrozen lakes, this is at best a hypothesis that needs an in depth study. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
bluewave Posted 16 hours ago Share Posted 16 hours ago 14 minutes ago, Dark Star said: That doesn't prove anything. Radiational cooling is always minimized with stronger winds, and is at it s peak with no winds. This theory is going nowhere without true modeling. While there may be a minute difference in warming from the unfrozen lakes, this is at best a hypothesis that needs an in depth study. What theory are you talking about? The planet has warmed tremendously since the 1970s. So even a roughly similar 500 mb pattern won’t be as cold. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LibertyBell Posted 16 hours ago Share Posted 16 hours ago 13 hours ago, gravitylover said: After an anamolously long period of easterlies. and hopefully a drier pattern after an anomalously wet period that lasted for a few decades. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
LibertyBell Posted 16 hours ago Share Posted 16 hours ago 13 minutes ago, bluewave said: What theory are you talking about? The planet has warmed tremendously since the 1970s. So even a roughly similar 500 mb pattern won’t be as cold. I think he's talking about the lakes causing higher night time lows for the east coast. Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now