2024 Hurricane season forecast contest -- entries now closed

[Roger Smith]

Okay noted in table. 

[CurlyHeadBarrett]

46 minutes ago, Roger Smith said:

Okay noted in table. 

 

Thanks!

[Roger Smith]

EDIT Sep 27 for Helene, and H Isaac and TS Joyce

EDIT Oct 3 for Kirk and Leslie

Count is now (set at) 12/8/3 (if Leslie becomes a 'cane, it is 12/7/3 now) ... "rest of season" forecasts are based on that probability. 

... your forecasts were already posted in an earlier table (and are repeated below table), this will be a "forecast of rest of season" for all entrants.

NOTE: Post no longer being edited, a later post is being edited ...

 

<<< DERIVED FORECASTS for REST of 2024 SEASON >>>

 

FORECASTER (order of entry) _____________storms _ hurr _ major 

TomCosgrave (IE-3) ________________________ 27 ____ 18 _____ 4

CurlyHeadBarrett (late) _____________________ 21 _____ 7 _____ 5 (will rank, ineligible to win)

karmac (7) __________________________________ 21 _____ 6 _____ 4

WYorksWeather (NW-5) _____________________20 _____ 9 _____ 5

LongBeachSurfFreak (10) ___________________ 20 _____ 4 _____ 1

nvck (8) _____________________________________ 17 _____ 7 _____ 2

Tezeta (16) __________________________________ 17 _____ 5 _____ 4

Jtm12180 (33) _______________________________ 16 _____ 8 _____ 4

WxWatcher007 (1) __________________________ 16 _____ 5 _____ 3

cnimbus (3) _________________________________ 15 _____ 9 _____ 3

Yanksfan (9) _________________________________15 _____ 9 _____ 2

ineedsnow (32) ______________________________15 _____ 6 _____ 5

metalicwx367 (34) __________________________ 14 _____ 7 _____ 4

LovintheWhiteFluff (31) ______________________ 14 _____ 5 _____ 3

SnowLover22 (43) __________________________ 14 _____ 5 _____ 3

Normandy (14) ______________________________ 13 _____ 9 _____ 7

Brian5671 (22) ______________________________ 13 _____ 8______ 0

Diggiebot (11) _______________________________ 13 _____ 6 _____ 5

Matty40s (NW-3) ___________________________ 13 _____ 4 _____ 4

ncforecaster89 (38) _________________________13 _____ 4 _____ 3

CHSVol (5) __________________________________ 13 _____ 4 _____ 2

JonClaw (23) ________________________________13 _____ 4 _____ 2

Big Jims Videos (21) ________________________ 13 _____ 4 _____ 1

wxdude64 (late) ____________________________ 13 _____ 0 _____ 2 (will rank, ineligible to win)

SnowenOutThere (39) _______________________12 _____ 6 _____ 3

ImleahBradley (19) __________________________ 12 _____ 6 _____ 1

IntenseWind002 (24) ________________________12 _____ 5 _____ 2

Stebo (17) ___________________________________ 12 _____ 4 _____ 2

Eyewall (late) ________________________________ 12 _____ 4 _____ 2 (will rank, ineligible to win)

DOCARCH (IE-2) ____________________________ 12 _____ 3 _____ 3

LakeNormanStormin (41) ____________________ 12 _____ 3 _____ 2

Roger Smith (20) ____________________________ 12 _____ 3 _____ 1

___ Contest consensus (Median) ___________ 12 _____ 4 _____ 2

StormchaserChuck1 (4) ______________________ 11 _____ 5 _____ 3

GeorgeBM (37) _______________________________11 _____ 5 _____ 3

FPizz (18) ____________________________________ 11 _____ 5 _____ 1

___ Expert consensus ________________________ 11 _____ 3 _____ 2

Hotair (28) ___________________________________ 11 _____ 3 _____ 1

Southmdwatcher (42) ________________________ 10 _____ 7 _____ 5

Snowlover2 (15) ______________________________ 10 _____ 6 _____ 3

cardinalland (26) _____________________________ 10 _____ 4 _____ 3

Yoda (30) _____________________________________10______ 4 _____ 2

___ UKMO forecast ___________________________ 10 _____ 4 _____ 1

Seminole (25) ________________________________ 10 _____ 3 _____ 0

Metwatch (NW-1) ____________________________ 10 _____ 2 _____ 1

ldub23 (40) ___________________________________ 9 _____ 3 _____ 2

___ NOAA median forecast ____________________ 9_____ 2.5 __ 2.5

Gawx (35) _____________________________________ 9 _____ 2 _____ 2

Pauldry (IE-1) __________________________________ 9 _____ 0 _____ 1

Rhino16 (2) ____________________________________ 8______ 4 _____ 2

Torch Tiger (13) _______________________________ 8 ______ 3 _____ 3

vpBob (27) ____________________________________ 8 ______ 1 _____ 2

jlauderdal (36) _________________________________ 7______ 1 _____ 2

dancerwithwings (NW-2) ______________________ 7______ 0 _____ 0

Kirkcaldy Weather (NW-4) _____________________ 6 ______3 _____ 2

Ed Snow and Hurricane Fan (6) __________________ 6 ______2 _____ 1

wkd (29) ________________________________________3 _____ 1 _____ 1

tae laidir (IE-4) _________________________________ 3 _____ 1 _____ 1

Retrobuc (12) ___________________________________ 1 ______ 0 ____(-1)

 

Consensus is median of on-time forecasts, late forecasts are not used.

Sep _ Now as Isaac reached h'cane, wxdude64 is first contest entrant to reach a position where numbers are not attainable (more majors than 'canes in this case). A number of others now have equal numbers of canes and majors required to complete forecast. 

Oct _ A few additional forecasts are now out of sequence, or need Leslie to reach major status. 

==============================

(original forecasts)

TomCosgrave (IE-3) ________________________ 39 _____ 26 ______ 7

CurlyHeadBarrett (late) _____________________ 33 _____ 15 ______ 8 (will rank, ineligible to win)

karmac (7) __________________________________ 33 _____ 14 ______ 7

WYorksWeather (NW-5) _____________________32 _____ 17 ______ 8

LongBeachSurfFreak (10) ___________________ 32 _____ 12 ______ 4

nvck (8) _____________________________________ 29 _____ 15 ______ 5

Tezeta (16) __________________________________ 29 _____ 13 ______ 7

Jtm12180 (33) _______________________________28 _____ 16 ______ 7

WxWatcher007 (1) __________________________ 28 _____ 13 ______ 6

cnimbus (3) _________________________________ 27 _____ 17 ______ 6

Yanksfan (9) _________________________________27 _____ 17 ______ 5

ineedsnow (32) ______________________________27 _____ 14 ______ 8

metalicwx367 (34) __________________________ 26 _____ 15 ______ 7

LovintheWhiteFluff (31) ______________________26 _____ 13 ______ 6

SnowLover22 (43) __________________________ 26 _____ 13 ______ 6

Normandy (14) ______________________________ 25 _____ 17 _____ 10

Brian5671 (22) ______________________________ 25 _____ 16 ______ 3

Diggiebot (11) _______________________________ 25 _____ 14 ______ 8

Matty40s (NW-3) ___________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 7

ncforecaster89 (38) ________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 6

CHSVol (5) __________________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 5

JonClaw (23) ________________________________25 _____ 12 ______ 5

Big Jims Videos (21) ________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 4

wxdude64 (late) ____________________________ 25 ______ 8 ______ 5 (will rank, ineligible to win)

SnowenOutThere (39) _______________________24 _____ 14 ______ 6

ImleahBradley (19) __________________________ 24 _____ 14 ______ 4

IntenseWind002 (24) ________________________24 _____ 13 ______ 5

Stebo (17) ___________________________________ 24 _____ 12 ______ 5

Eyewall (late) ________________________________24 _____ 12 ______ 5 (will rank, ineligible to win)

DOCARCH (IE-2) ____________________________ 24 _____ 11 ______ 6

LakeNormanStormin (41) ____________________24 _____ 11 ______ 5

Roger Smith (20) ____________________________24 _____ 11 ______ 4

___ Contest consensus (Median) __________ 24 _____ 12 _____ 5

StormchaserChuck1 (4) _____________________23 _____ 13 ______ 6

GeorgeBM (37) ______________________________23 _____ 13 ______ 6

FPizz (18) ___________________________________ 23 _____ 13 ______ 4

___ Expert consensus _______________________ 23 _____ 11 ______ 5

Hotair (28) __________________________________ 23 _____ 11 ______ 4

Southmdwatcher (42) _______________________22 _____ 15 ______ 8

Snowlover2 (15) _____________________________22 _____ 14 ______ 6

cardinalland (26) ____________________________ 22 _____ 12 ______ 6

Yoda (30) ____________________________________22 _____ 12 ______ 5

___ UKMO forecast __________________________ 22 _____ 12 ______ 4

Seminole (25) _______________________________ 22 _____ 11 ______ 3

Metwatch (NW-1) ___________________________ 22 _____ 10 ______ 4

ldub23 (40) __________________________________21 _____ 11 ______ 5

___ NOAA median forecast __________________ 21 _____ 10.5 ___ 5.5

Gawx (35) ___________________________________21 _____ 10 ______ 5

Pauldry (IE-1) ________________________________21 ______ 8 ______ 4

Rhino16 (2) __________________________________20 _____ 12 ______ 5

Torch Tiger (13) _____________________________20 _____ 11 ______ 6

vpBob (27) __________________________________20 ______ 9 ______ 5

jlauderdal (36) ______________________________ 19 ______ 9 ______ 5

dancerwithwings (NW-2) ____________________19 ______ 8 ______ 3

Kirkcaldy Weather (NW-4) ___________________18 _____ 11 ______ 5

Ed Snow and Hurricane Fan (6) _______________ 18 _____ 10 ______ 4

wkd (29) _____________________________________15 ______ 9 ______ 4

tae laidir (IE-4) ______________________________ 15 ______ 9 ______ 4

Retrobuc (12) ________________________________ 13 ______ 8 ______ 2

 

--------------------------

(previous notes)

If season is 50% done and stays on current intensity, end result is 12 8 2

Our consensus says season is 1/4 done. 

All forecasts (were) still "valid" (do not involve unattainable values e.g. 9 _ 3 _ 4) (since updated)

Table is updated for every new storm once its full development is confirmed.  

[Roger Smith]

"Rest of season" forecasts look like a typical full season forecast list. Our consensus (and expert consensus not a lot lower) now needs a very robust Sep-Oct to verify. 

Rest of season values can be seen in previous post above original forecast table. 

Count is 5/3/1. 

[Roger Smith]

Count is 6/4/1. Will probably be 7/4/1 soon if TD Seven is a named storm (later edit, TS Gordon).

For now, table of "storms needed to verify" is based on 6/4/1, will re-edit if we are at 7/4/1. 

(table is two posts back now) ...

Gordon's fate is not clear, may eventually become a weak 'cane. Table is now edited for 7/4/1 for now.

 

[Roger Smith]

Table of storms (two posts back) still needed to verify forecasts is updated for likely events taking Helene to major next day or so. Also Isaac now a TS (edit _ and now a 'cane, not progged to be very strong). Also we now welcome Joyce, predicted to remain a TS.

At 10/6/2 season if 70% done will end at 13/9/3 so almost all forecasts need a strong OCT-NOV to stand any real possibility of contest success now. A 5/4/2 Oct brings it to 15/10/4 and a 2/1/0 NOV to 17/11/4, so even stronger actual results would be needed by most of us. 

 

[Roger Smith]

Kirk brought count to 11/7/3 and Leslie to 12/7/3, very likely to go (edit now is) 12/8/3 (and probably not 12/8/4) so will edit "rest of season forecast" table several posts back now, based on 12/8/3. Next edit will also go forward to latest post. 

Edit is now added to post ...

Oct 6 _ new edit for Milton (1/1/1 is being added now) ... count will be 13/9/4

Oct 19 _ Nadine, Oscar boost count to 15/10/4.

Nov 3 _ Patty to 16/10/4 and edit for PTC 18 being at least a TS, potential count 17/10/4. 

Nov 6 _ Rafael now brings count to 17/11/5

As a scoring post contains following info, it will now be deleted, see Nov 4 post as edited for updates.

 

 

 

[Roger Smith]

Milton brings count to 13/8/3 and I edited table above for 13/9/3 as per guidance. 

(Oct 6 _ count is now 13/9/3 and table is now based on 13/9/4 as guidance strongly suggests further intensification).

If season ended 13/9/3 scores would be Retrobuc 98.0 and wkd, tae laidir 97.5.

Currently next in scoring is Ed Snow and Hurricane Fan at 90.5; KWx is 86.5 and dww is 88.5.

If season ended 13/9/4 scores would be wkd, tae laidir 98.5, and Retrobuc 96.0

13/9/4 _ (Ed Snow and Hurricane Fan at 91.5; KWx is 87.5 and dww is 87.5)

Top half of table need more storms to start scoring ... 24 (error 11) storms gives an error deduction of 66 (net score 34) so basically if your forecast was 25 or less and you have a reasonable forecast of H and M, your score is positive.

(storm errors count 50% relative to H and M errors) 

Will get into scoring details later in OCT ... looks like 16/10/4 could be a target, if so, contest winner would be Ed. 

 

[Roger Smith]

Nadine boosts count to 14/9/4. Table edited. 

[wncsnow]

Better edit again

[Roger Smith]

Oscar brings count to 15/10/4, edit in progress. 

[SnowLover22]

On 10/19/2024 at 12:20 PM, Roger Smith said:

Oscar brings count to 15/10/4, edit in progress. 

Do you consider post-season upgrades?  Unlikely event Oscar gets upgraded to cat 3 months later 

[Roger Smith]

I would certainly note it and discuss alternate scoring result but contest will be "settled" as of Jan 1st count report. 

[Roger Smith]

Patty brough the count to 16/10/4 and PTC 18 will bring it to 17/10/4 if a TS is declared (and to 17/11/4 if a 'cane is result). Table edited to reflect likely 17/10/4 count soon.

 

 

[Roger Smith]

Scoring for contest possible results

 

(note Nov 15, 18/11/5 is now basis of table errors, and 18/12/5, 18/12/6 will be added to potential scores. As 18 is confirmed, 17/11/5 scores were removed

(note Nov 19, Sara only a TS, 18/12/5 and 18/12/6 are now 19/11/5 and 20/11/5 in case one or two more TS develop before end of Dec. 

reminder, error point deductions from 100 are scored by formula (E + E^2) / 2, except that storm errors are (E + E^2) / 4. A total score below zero is adjusted to zero. (E = category error).

 

Residual errors for 18/11/5

 

FORECASTER (order of entry) _________storms_hurr_major __ 18 11 5 _ 19 11 5 _ 20 11 5

 

TomCosgrave (IE-3) _____________________ 21 ___ 15 ____ 2 _____ 0.0 ____ 0.0 ___ 0.0

(for context, 21 0 0 scores -15.5, 21 15 2 scores -138.5)

CurlyHeadBarrett (late) __________________ 15 ____ 4 ____ 3 _____18.0 ___ 25.5 __ 32.5

karmac (7) ________________________________15 ____ 3 ____ 2 _____31.0 ___ 38.5 __ 45.5

WYorksWeather (NW-5) __________________14 ____ 6 ____ 3 _____20.5 ___ 27.5 __ 34.0

LongBeachSurfFreak (10) ________________ 14 ____ 1 ____(-1)____45.5 ___ 52.5 __ 59.0

nvck (8) __________________________________ 11 ____ 4 ____ 0 _____57.0 ___ 62.5 __ 67.5

Tezeta (16) _______________________________ 11 ____ 2 ____ 2 _____61.0 ___ 66.5 __ 71.5

Jtm12180 (33) ____________________________ 10 ____ 5 ____ 2 _____54.5 ___ 59.5 __ 64.0

WxWatcher007 (1) ________________________10 ____ 2 ____ 1 _____ 68.5 ___ 73.5 __ 78.0

cnimbus (3) _______________________________ 9____ 6 ____ 1 _____ 55.5 ___ 60.0 __ 64.5

Yanksfan (9) ______________________________ 9____ 6 ____ 0 _____ 56.5 ___ 61.5 __ 66.0

ineedsnow (32) ___________________________ 9 ____ 3 ____ 3 _____65.5 ___ 70.5 __ 75.0

metalicwx367 (34) ________________________ 8 ____ 4 ____ 2 _____69.0 ___ 73.0 __ 76.5

LovintheWhiteFluff (31) ____________________8 ____ 2 ____ 1 _____ 78.0 ___ 82.0 __ 85.5

SnowLover22 (43) ________________________ 8 ____ 2 ____ 1 _____ 78.0 ___ 82.0 __ 85.5

Normandy (14) ____________________________ 7 ____ 6 ____ 5 _____50.0 ___ 53.5 __ 56.5

Brian5671 (22) ____________________________ 7 ____ 5 ____(-2) ____67.0 ___ 70.5 __ 73.5

Diggiebot (11) ______________________________7 ____ 3 ____ 3 _____74.0 ___ 77.5 __ 80.5

Matty40s (NW-3) _________________________ 7 ____ 1 ____ 2 _____ 82.0 ___ 85.5 __ 88.5

ncforecaster89 (38) _______________________7 ____ 1 ____ 1 _____ 84.0 ___ 87.5 __ 90.5

CHSVol (5) ________________________________ 7 ____ 1 ____ 0 _____85.0 ___ 88.5 __ 91.5

JonClaw (23) ______________________________7 ____ 1 ____ 0 _____85.0 ___ 88.5 __ 91.5

Big Jims Videos (21) ______________________ 7 ____ 1 ____(-1)_____84.0 ___ 87.5 __ 90.5

wxdude64 (late) ___________________________7 ___(-3) ___ 0 _____80.0 ___ 83.5 __ 86.5

SnowenOutThere (39) ____________________ 6 ____ 3 ____ 1 _____ 82.5 ___ 85.5 __ 88.0

ImleahBradley (19) ________________________ 6 ____ 3 ____(-1)____82.5 ___ 85.5 __ 88.0

IntenseWind002 (24) ______________________6 ____ 2 ____ 0 _____86.5 ___ 89.5 __ 92.0

Stebo (17) _________________________________ 6 ____ 1 ____ 0 _____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

Eyewall (late) ______________________________ 6 ____ 1 ____ 0 _____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

DOCARCH (IE-2) ___________________________6 ____ 0 ____ 1 _____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

LakeNormanStormin (41) ___________________6 ____ 0 ____ 0 ____89.5 ___ 92.5 __ 95.0

Roger Smith (20) ___________________________6 ____ 0 ____(-1)____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

___ Contest consensus (Median) _________ 6  ____ 1 ____ 0 ____ 88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

StormchaserChuck1 (4) ____________________5 ____ 2 ____ 1 _____ 88.5 ___ 91.0 __ 93.0

GeorgeBM (37) _____________________________5 ____ 2 ____1 _____ 88.5 ___ 91.0 __ 93.0

FPizz (18) __________________________________ 5 ____ 2 ____(-1)___ 88.5 ___ 91.0 __ 93.0

___ Expert consensus ______________________ 5 ____ 0 ____ 0 _____92.5 ___ 95.0 __ 97.0

Hotair (28) _________________________________ 5 ____ 0 ____(-1)____ 91.5 ___ 94.0 __ 96.0

Southmdwatcher (42) ______________________ 4 ____ 4 ____ 3 ____ 79.0 ___ 81.0 __ 82.5

Snowlover2 (15) ____________________________ 4 ____ 3 ____ 1 _____ 88.0 ___ 90.0  __ 91.5

cardinalland (26) ___________________________ 4 ____ 1 ____ 1 _____  93.0 ___ 95.0 __ 96.5

Yoda (30) ___________________________________4 ____ 1 ____ 0 _____ 94.0 ___ 96.0 __ 97.5

___ UKMO forecast _________________________ 4 ____ 1 ____(-1)____ 93.0 ___ 95.0 __ 96.5

Seminole (25) _______________________________4 ____ 0 ___(-2) ____ 92.0 ___ 94.0 __ 95.5

Metwatch (NW-1) ___________________________ 4 ____(-1)___(-1)____ 93.0 ___ 95.0 __ 96.5

ldub23 (40) _________________________________ 3 ____ 0 ____ 0 _____ 95.0 ___ 96.5 __ 97.5

___ NOAA median forecast __________________ 3 ___-0.5 __0.5 ____ 96.2 ___ 97.7 __ 98.7

Gawx (35) ___________________________________ 3 ____(-1)____ 0 ____ 96.0 ___ 97.5 __ 98.5

Pauldry (IE-1) ________________________________ 3 ____(-3)___(-1) ___ 90.0 ___ 91.5 __ 92.5

Rhino16 (2) ___________________________________2 ____ 1 ____ 0 _____ 97.5 ___ 98.5 __ 99.0

Torch Tiger (13) ______________________________2 ____ 0 ____ 1 _____ 97.5 ___ 98.5 __ 99.0

vpBob (27) ___________________________________2 ____(-2)___0 _____ 95.5 ___ 96.5 __ 97.0

jlauderdal (36) _______________________________ 1 ____(-2)___ 0 _____96.5 ___ 97.0 __ 96.5

dancerwithwings (NW-2) ____________________ 1 ___ (-3) __(-2)____ 90.5 ___ 91.0 __ 90.5

Kirkcaldy Weather (NW-4) ____________________0 _____ 0 ____ 0 ___100.0 ___99.5 __ 98.5

Ed Snow and Hurricane Fan (6) ______________ 0_____(-1) ___(-1)____98.0 ___ 97.5 __ 96.5

wkd (29) _____________________________________(-3) ___(-2) __(-1)____93.0 ___ 91.0 __ 88.5

tae laidir (IE-4) _______________________________(-3)___ (-2) __(-1)____93.0 ___ 91.0 __ 88.5

Retrobuc (12) _________________________________(-5)___(-3)__(-3)____80.5 ___ 77.5 __ 74.0

______________________________

Kirkcaldy Weather (Net-wx) (KW below) wins at 18/11/5 and also 19/11/5 .

Rhino16 and Torch Tiger would overtake at 20/11/5.

We're not going to know the results for several weeks at least. 

 

<<< Table will be re-ordered closer to end of contest to include ranks)

---------------------------------

 

(original forecasts)

TomCosgrave (IE-3) ________________________ 39 _____ 26 ______ 7

CurlyHeadBarrett (late) _____________________ 33 _____ 15 ______ 8 (will rank, ineligible to win)

karmac (7) __________________________________ 33 _____ 14 ______ 7

WYorksWeather (NW-5) _____________________32 _____ 17 ______ 8

LongBeachSurfFreak (10) ___________________ 32 _____ 12 ______ 4

nvck (8) _____________________________________ 29 _____ 15 ______ 5

Tezeta (16) __________________________________ 29 _____ 13 ______ 7

Jtm12180 (33) _______________________________28 _____ 16 ______ 7

WxWatcher007 (1) __________________________ 28 _____ 13 ______ 6

cnimbus (3) _________________________________ 27 _____ 17 ______ 6

Yanksfan (9) _________________________________27 _____ 17 ______ 5

ineedsnow (32) ______________________________27 _____ 14 ______ 8

metalicwx367 (34) __________________________ 26 _____ 15 ______ 7

LovintheWhiteFluff (31) ______________________26 _____ 13 ______ 6

SnowLover22 (43) __________________________ 26 _____ 13 ______ 6

Normandy (14) ______________________________ 25 _____ 17 _____ 10

Brian5671 (22) ______________________________ 25 _____ 16 ______ 3

Diggiebot (11) _______________________________ 25 _____ 14 ______ 8

Matty40s (NW-3) ___________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 7

ncforecaster89 (38) ________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 6

CHSVol (5) __________________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 5

JonClaw (23) ________________________________25 _____ 12 ______ 5

Big Jims Videos (21) ________________________ 25 _____ 12 ______ 4

wxdude64 (late) ____________________________ 25 ______ 8 ______ 5 (will rank, ineligible to win)

SnowenOutThere (39) _______________________24 _____ 14 ______ 6

ImleahBradley (19) __________________________ 24 _____ 14 ______ 4

IntenseWind002 (24) ________________________24 _____ 13 ______ 5

Stebo (17) ___________________________________ 24 _____ 12 ______ 5

Eyewall (late) ________________________________24 _____ 12 ______ 5 (will rank, ineligible to win)

DOCARCH (IE-2) ____________________________ 24 _____ 11 ______ 6

LakeNormanStormin (41) ____________________24 _____ 11 ______ 5

Roger Smith (20) ____________________________24 _____ 11 ______ 4

___ Contest consensus (Median) __________ 24 _____ 12 _____ 5

StormchaserChuck1 (4) _____________________23 _____ 13 ______ 6

GeorgeBM (37) _____________________________ 23 _____ 13 ______ 6

FPizz (18) ___________________________________ 23 _____ 13 ______ 4

___ Expert consensus _______________________ 23 _____ 11 ______ 5

Hotair (28) __________________________________ 23 _____ 11 ______ 4

Southmdwatcher (42) _______________________22 _____ 15 ______ 8

Snowlover2 (15) _____________________________22 _____ 14 ______ 6

cardinalland (26) ____________________________ 22 _____ 12 ______ 6

Yoda (30) ____________________________________22 _____ 12 ______ 5

___ UKMO forecast __________________________ 22 _____ 12 ______ 4

Seminole (25) _______________________________ 22 _____ 11 ______ 3

Metwatch (NW-1) ___________________________ 22 _____ 10 ______ 4

ldub23 (40) __________________________________21 _____ 11 ______ 5

___ NOAA median forecast __________________ 21 _____ 10.5 ___ 5.5

Gawx (35) ___________________________________21 _____ 10 ______ 5

Pauldry (IE-1) ________________________________21 ______ 8 ______ 4

Rhino16 (2) __________________________________20 _____ 12 ______ 5

Torch Tiger (13) _____________________________20 _____ 11 ______ 6

vpBob (27) __________________________________20 ______ 9 ______ 5

jlauderdal (36) ______________________________ 19 ______ 9 ______ 5

dancerwithwings (NW-2) ____________________19 ______ 8 ______ 3

Kirkcaldy Weather (NW-4) ___________________18 _____ 11 ______ 5

Ed Snow and Hurricane Fan (6) _______________ 18 _____ 10 ______ 4

wkd (29) _____________________________________15 ______ 9 ______ 4

tae laidir (IE-4) ______________________________ 15 ______ 9 ______ 4

Retrobuc (12) ________________________________ 13 ______ 8 ______ 2

 

--------------------------

[Roger Smith]

If Sara arrives, count would go to 18/11/5 and possibly 18/12/5 or even 18/12/6. I already had 18/11/5 scoring in tables in previous post, and have now added  18/12/5 and 18/12/6 FYI. 

I also indicate what any later 19th named storm would mean for scoring leaders. I would not be too surprised by a late Nov or Dec TS add-on, or even two more? 

This season was looking like an under-performer relative to expectations, but now it looks like we got all but the August portion and the consensus of our hurricane and major forecasts has already peaked in potential scoring (same for NWS and expert consensus).

Kirkcaldy Weather (Net-weather entrant) will have a perfect forecast if and when Sara does arrive, and would then lose a point for each occasion that Sara intensifies to hurricane or even major. Even so, their points total remains in the lead for any Sara outcome. A number of American Weather entrants are 0.5 to 2.0 behind various Sara outcomes, and could move past Kirkcaldy Weather if a 19th named storm appeared later. 

(all scoring details in previous post)

 

 

[Roger Smith]

As Sara never went past TS, scoring table is edited to present scoring for 18/11/5 and potential scoring if we go to 19/11/5 and even 20/11/5. 

[Roger Smith]

New table for contest scoring, placing scores in rank order

 

Ranks are (a) overall contest and (b) within your forum

Ranks of non-contest entities do not affect entrant ranks.

Table will be adjusted if any more activity develops. 

 

Ranks _ FORECASTER (order of entry) _____storms_hurr_major __ 18 11 5 _ 19 11 5 _ 20 11 5

(a) (b) __________________________________________ errors (18 11 5) __

_ 1 _1 __Kirkcaldy Weather (NW-4) _______________0 ____ 0 ___ 0 ___100.0 ___99.5 __ 98.5

_2 _1 __Ed Snow and Hurricane Fan (6) __________0____(-1) __(-1)____98.0 ___97.5 __ 96.5

_3 _2 __Rhino16 (2) ______________________________2 ___ 1 ___ 0 _____ 97.5 ___ 98.5 __ 99.0

_4 _3 __Torch Tiger (13) _________________________ 2 ___ 0 ___ 1 _____ 97.5 ___ 98.5 __ 99.0

_5 _4 __jlauderdal (36) ___________________________1 ___(-2)__ 0 _____96.5 ___ 97.0 __ 96.5

(5.6) ______ NOAA median forecast _____________ 3 __-0.5__0.5 ____96.2 ___ 97.7 __ 98.7

_6 _5 __Gawx (35) _______________________________3 ___(-1)___0 ____ 96.0 ___ 97.5 __ 98.5

_7 _6 __vpBob (27) ______________________________ 2 ___(-2)__0 _____95.5 ___ 96.5 __ 97.0

_8 _7 __ldub23 (40) _____________________________ 3 ___ 0 ___ 0 ____ 95.0 ___ 96.5 __ 97.5

_9 _8 __Yoda (30) _______________________________ 4 ___ 1 ___ 0 _____94.0 ___ 96.0 __ 97.5

10 _9 __Seminole (25) ___________________________ 4 ___ 0 __(-2) ____92.0 ___ 94.0 __ 95.5

11 _10__cardinalland (26) ________________________ 4 ___ 1 ___ 1 _____ 93.0 ___ 95.0 __ 96.5

12 _2 __Metwatch (NW-1) _______________________ 4 ___(-1)__(-1)____93.0 ___ 95.0 __ 96.5

(10) _____ UKMO forecast _______________________ 4 ___ 1 ___(-1)____ 93.0 ___ 95.0 __ 96.5

13 _11__wkd (29) _______________________________ (-3)___(-2)__(-1)___93.0 ___ 91.0 __ 88.5

14 _1 ___tae laidir (IE-4) _________________________(-3)__ (-2)__(-1)___93.0 ___ 91.0 __ 88.5

(14.5) _______ Expert consensus ________________ 5 ___ 0 ___ 0 _____92.5 ___ 95.0 __ 97.0

15 _12 __Hotair (28) _____________________________ 5 ___ 0 ___(-1)____ 91.5 ___ 94.0 __ 96.0

16 _ 3 __dancerwithwings (NW-2) ______________ 1 __ (-3)__(-2)____ 90.5 ___ 91.0 __ 90.5

17 _ 2 __Pauldry (IE-1) __________________________ 3 ___(-3)__(-1) ___ 90.0 ___ 91.5 __ 92.5

18 _13 __LakeNormanStormin (41) ______________ 6 ___ 0 ___ 0 ____ 89.5 ___ 92.5 __ 95.0

(19) ___ Contest consensus (Median) __________6  ___ 1 ___ 0 ____ 88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

19 _14 __StormchaserChuck1 (4) ________________5 ___ 2 ___ 1 _____ 88.5 ___ 91.0 __ 93.0

20 _15 __Stebo (17) _____________________________ 6 ___ 1 ___ 0 _____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

21 _16 __FPizz (18) ______________________________ 5 ___ 2 ___(-1)___ 88.5 ___ 91.0 __ 93.0

22 _ 3 __DOCARCH (IE-2) _______________________6 ___ 0 ___ 1 _____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

23 _17 __Roger Smith (20) _______________________6 ___ 0 ___(-1)____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

24 _18 __GeorgeBM (37) ________________________ 5 ___ 2 ___ 1 _____ 88.5 ___ 91.0 __ 93.0

25 _19 __Eyewall (late) __________________________ 6 ___ 1 ___ 0 _____88.5 ___ 91.5 __ 94.0

26 _20 __Snowlover2 (15) _______________________4 ___ 3 ___ 1 _____ 88.0 ___ 90.0  __ 91.5

27 _21 __IntenseWind002 (24) __________________6 ___ 2 ___ 0 _____86.5 ___ 89.5 __ 92.0

28 _22 __CHSVol (5) ____________________________ 7 ___ 1 ___ 0 _____ 85.0 ___ 88.5 __ 91.5

29 _23 __JonClaw (23) __________________________7 ___ 1 ___ 0 _____85.0 ___ 88.5 __ 91.5

30 _24 __Big Jims Videos (21) __________________ 7 ___ 1 ___(-1)_____84.0 ___ 87.5 __ 90.5

31 _25 __ncforecaster89 (38) ___________________ 7 ___ 1 ___ 1 ______ 84.0 ___ 87.5 __ 90.5

32 _26 __ImleahBradley (19) ____________________ 6 ___ 3 ___(-1)____82.5 ___ 85.5 __ 88.0

33 _27 __SnowenOutThere (39) ________________ 6 ___ 3 ___ 1 _____ 82.5 ___ 85.5 __ 88.0

34 _ 4 __Matty40s (NW-3) _____________________ 7 ____ 1 ____ 2 _____82.0 ___ 85.5 __ 88.5

35 _28 __Retrobuc (12) _________________________(-5)__(-3)__(-3)____80.5 ___ 77.5 __ 74.0

36 _29 __wxdude64 (late) _______________________7___(-3) __ 0 _____ 80.0 ___ 83.5 __ 86.5

37 _30 __Southmdwatcher (42) _________________ 4 ___ 4 ___ 3 _____ 79.0 ___ 81.0 __ 82.5

38 _31 __LovintheWhiteFluff (31) ________________ 8 ___ 2 ___ 1 _____ 78.0 ___ 82.0 __ 85.5

39 _32 __SnowLover22 (43) ____________________ 8 ___ 2 ___ 1 _____ 78.0 ___ 82.0 __ 85.5

40 _33 __Diggiebot (11) _________________________ 7 ___ 3 ___ 3 _____ 74.0 ___ 77.5 __ 80.5

41 _34 __metalicwx367 (34) ____________________ 8 ___ 4 ___ 2 _____ 69.0 ___ 73.0 __ 76.5

42 _35 __WxWatcher007 (1) ___________________ 10 ___ 2 ___ 1 _____ 68.5 ___ 73.5 __ 78.0

43 _36 __Brian5671 (22) ________________________ 7 ___ 5 ___(-2) ____67.0 ___ 70.5 __ 73.5

44 _37 __ineedsnow (32) _______________________ 9 ___ 3 ___ 3 _____65.5 ___ 70.5 __ 75.0

45 _38 __Tezeta (16) ___________________________ 11 ___ 2 ___ 2 _____61.0 ___ 66.5 __ 71.5

46 _39 __nvck (8) ______________________________ 11 ___ 4 ___ 0 _____57.0 ___ 62.5 __ 67.5

47 _40 __Yanksfan (9) __________________________ 9___ 6 ___ 0 _____ 56.5 ___ 61.5 __ 66.0

48 _41 __cnimbus (3) ___________________________ 9___ 6 ___ 1 _____ 55.5 ___ 60.0 __ 64.5

49 _42 __Jtm12180 (33) ________________________ 10 ___ 5 ___ 2 _____54.5 ___ 59.5 __ 64.0

50 _43 __Normandy (14) ________________________ 7 ___ 6 ___ 5 _____50.0 ___ 53.5 __ 56.5

51 _44 __LongBeachSurfFreak (10) _____________14 ___ 1 ___(-1)____45.5 ___ 52.5 __ 59.0

52 _45 __karmac (7) ____________________________15 ___ 3 ___ 2 _____31.0 ___ 38.5 __ 45.5

53 _ 5 __WYorksWeather (NW-5) _______________14 ___ 6 ___ 3 _____20.5 ___ 27.5 __ 34.0

54 _ 46 __CurlyHeadBarrett (late) ______________ 15 ___ 4 ___ 3 _____18.0 ___ 25.5 __ 32.5

55 _ 4 __TomCosgrave (IE-3) ___________________21 __ 15 ___ 2 _____ 0.0 ____ 0.0 ___ 0.0

(for context, 21 0 0 scores -15.5, 21 15 2 scores -138.5)

______________________________

Kirkcaldy Weather (Net-wx) (KW below) wins at 18/11/5 and also 19/11/5 .

Rhino16 and Torch Tiger would overtake at 20/11/5.

We're not going to know the results for several weeks at least.