Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,607
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    NH8550
    Newest Member
    NH8550
    Joined

Central PA - Winter 2020/2021


MAG5035
 Share

Recommended Posts

12 minutes ago, canderson said:

Yup. I'm not counting on any coastal snow from this. Primary/WAA is the only thing I'd trust. 

I'm not sure where that's coming from?  The NAO is starting to relax and YES, we had a shred factory over the last couple weeks (and still do),  BUT what you are forgetting, is that the shredder is running outta gas this weekend, and the upcoming event just has a nice antecedent airmass to work with, and its deep enough to keep most out of worry for taint, but is not the big bully it once was which gives this storm a chance to lift and not suppress.    

Point is, you cant just say "atmospheric memory" when the base state is changing.  It's been said many times....gotta pay attention to 500's/700's and not just surface. 

EDIT - and fwiw, I'm not saying in the end that you arent correct, but you cant just look at this storm the same way we've been for the last several weeks.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, pasnownut said:

I'm not sure where that's coming from?  The NAO is starting to relax and YES, we had a shred factory over the last couple weeks (and still do),  BUT what you are forgetting, is that the shredder is running outta gas this weekend, and the upcoming event just has a nice antecedent airmass to work with, and its deep enough to keep most out of worry for taint, but is not the big bully it once was which gives this storm a chance to lift and not suppress.    

Point is, you cant just say "atmospheric memory" when the base state is changing.  It's been said many times....gotta pay attention to 500's/700's and not just surface. 

EDIT - and fwiw, I'm not saying in the end that you arent correct, but you cant just look at this storm the same way we've been for the last several weeks.  

I maintain that confluence can erode that WAA - the confluence has been trending stronger, not weakening. 

Your point in general about the differences in each setup and things change over time is well noted and prudent. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 minutes ago, pasnownut said:

I'm not sure where that's coming from?  The NAO is starting to relax and YES, we had a shred factory over the last couple weeks (and still do),  BUT what you are forgetting, is that the shredder is running outta gas this weekend, and the upcoming event just has a nice antecedent airmass to work with, and its deep enough to keep most out of worry for taint, but is not the big bully it once was which gives this storm a chance to lift and not suppress.    

Point is, you cant just say "atmospheric memory" when the base state is changing.  It's been said many times....gotta pay attention to 500's/700's and not just surface. 

EDIT - and fwiw, I'm not saying in the end that you arent correct, but you cant just look at this storm the same way we've been for the last several weeks.  

Very true but we have definitive trends here with these runs. I have to think they're picking up some atmoshperic info I can't see.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, anotherman said:

Many of us are so close to getting a memorable storm or getting just a few inches.  Hopefully it comes into focus over the next 24 hours, but something tells me it won't.  Lots of radar hallucinations.

LOL. Radar Hallucinations will be high. Just Yesterday we were pretty much bullseye to now most fringed in these trends today. It will be a fun couple of days. Banking on the ICON and NAM to keep the hopes alive. GFS as well, it wasn't bad but such a cutoff. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

At this point given the trends, I would say this is a non-issue for anyone north of US 22 and it's quickly on the verge of becoming one for anyone north of the PA Turnpike. Somebody earlier in the week jackpotted Warrenton, Virginia, and that may very well end up being right. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

From PSU I like this:

There are 2 obvious camps emerging in the guidance... and it involves how they are handling the upstream feature in New England.  Those that are diving the vort there further southwest are suppressing the flow (NAM/Euro) and causing the trough to remain more positive with a more suppressed east solution WRT the coastal.  Then a camp that is less suppressive with that feature (GFS/PARA/ICON).    The GGEM/RGEM are kind of in between and so we see probably the ideal result for 95.  There is honestly no way to know for sure what is going to happen with that feature in New England, but it holds the key here IMO.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Atomixwx said:

At this point given the trends, I would say this is a non-issue for anyone north of US 22 and it's quickly on the verge of becoming one for anyone north of the PA Turnpike. Somebody earlier in the week jackpotted Warrenton, Virginia, and that may very well end up being right. 

I’d agree with this, I’m only focused on scraps I can get with the primary. Coastal looking less likely north of turnpike.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, canderson said:

Very true but we have definitive trends here with these runs. I have to think they're picking up some atmoshperic info I can't see.  

Ok....I'll play..........

On monday you had a storm that was knee deep in the shred factory that ended up having taint all the way to the NY border (potter tioga had sleet).  It was NOT modeled to do so.  3 days later you have a storm that was slated to hammer us a week earlier, end up in central NC (spoke to a client 40 min south of Apex NC and she had 2" snow yesterday).  That was all during our shutout shredder NAO pattern.  Point I'm making is that while this pattern has been stable, systems can and will attack and cannot just assume they'll adjust south.  This one has a 1002mb lp trying to cut and will do its best, BUT while the air is deep and cold enough to force under and redevelops off coast the NAO is lifting out giving the coastal pop @ OBX a chance to come north and do a loopdyloop  because of it.  Several nooners ticked back W with MSLP.  If they all started to go east, I'd be buyin what you and trainer are selling. 

Still enough uncertainty exists to not discount, tucked/more northerly adjustments as we approach go time. 

Just my .02.

  

  • Like 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Anyone want a storm update? The energy for our SUN/MON storm is now coming thru CA & NV with snow & rain. Low pressure will develop over OK on Saturday and track to OH on Sunday...then re-develop off the VA coast Sunday PM into Monday. This type of "jump storm" is very complex...
 
...and they are known to give forecasters (and snow lovers) fits. #bustpotential That said, if things play out just right...then snowfall would exceed our December storm. But given the complexity of the playing field, it would be imprudent to be talking "numbers" today... #nohype
 
Saturday AM is the right time to make the call on snowfall. Check back. Timing: Light snow is likely Sunday afternoon w/ the steadiest snow (or mix) late Sunday night into Monday...tapering off by Tuesday AM. Bust factors: Sharp northern edge, dry slot, sleet, coastal low track.
 
Horst's thoughts. 
 
 
  • Like 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Itstrainingtime said:
Anyone want a storm update? The energy for our SUN/MON storm is now coming thru CA & NV with snow & rain. Low pressure will develop over OK on Saturday and track to OH on Sunday...then re-develop off the VA coast Sunday PM into Monday. This type of "jump storm" is very complex...
 
...and they are known to give forecasters (and snow lovers) fits. #bustpotential That said, if things play out just right...then snowfall would exceed our December storm. But given the complexity of the playing field, it would be imprudent to be talking "numbers" today... #nohype
 
Saturday AM is the right time to make the call on snowfall. Check back. Timing: Light snow is likely Sunday afternoon w/ the steadiest snow (or mix) late Sunday night into Monday...tapering off by Tuesday AM. Bust factors: Sharp northern edge, dry slot, sleet, coastal low track.
 
Horst's thoughts. 
 
 

So he's basically as divided/unsure as we are.....

awesome!!

 

  • Haha 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, pasnownut said:

Ok....I'll play..........

On monday you had a storm that was knee deep in the shred factory that ended up having taint all the way to the NY border (potter tioga had sleet).  It was NOT modeled to do so.  3 days later you have a storm that was slated to hammer us a week earlier, end up in central NC (spoke to a client 40 min south of Apex NC and she had 2" snow yesterday).  That was all during our shutout shredder NAO pattern.  Point I'm making is that while this pattern has been stable, systems can and will attack and cannot just assume they'll adjust south.  This one has a 1002mb lp trying to cut and will do its best, BUT while the air is deep and cold enough to force under and redevelops off coast the NAO is lifting out giving the coastal pop @ OBX a chance to come north and do a loopdyloop  because of it.  Several nooners ticked back W with MSLP.  If they all started to go east, I'd be buyin what you and trainer are selling. 

Still enough uncertainty exists to not discount, tucked/more northerly adjustments as we approach go time. 

Just my .02.

  

To be fair, I'm not selling. I'm trying to have a balanced discussion including hype, logic, reason, and everything in between. I'm not rooting against this nor do I hope that I'm right in what I'm thinking right now. I'm here for one reason, it's not to play poo poo or to be a pain in the arse. But things have happened, are happening, and I'm offering a counterpoint. I will try and post actual weather updates going forward and leave my thoughts and opinions out of here.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

13 minutes ago, Jonesy56 said:

12z GFS-para is a huge hit for most everyone just to add to the chaos..

 

 

and why we cannot discount norther solutions.  Base state is changing. 

I'd bet the most house money on the model that handles thermal profiles the best and see where it sends the storm. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...