Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,609
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    Vesuvius
    Newest Member
    Vesuvius
    Joined

Jan 4-5 Mixed Bag Discussion Thread


Bostonseminole
 Share

Recommended Posts

16 minutes ago, Ginx snewx said:

Brier scores on the Euro greatly outpace the others. What JSPIN is looking for is sensible wx scores. There is a lot of data online available for review. 

The thing with 500 MB Heights, is that small differences in scores actually could represent rather important differences with spatial outcomes. It may look statistically insignificant, but those differences could represent small differences in placements of ridges and troughs at Day “X”  but the sensible wx outcome for a specific point could vary quite a bit based on these differences.  In general at day 3 we expect all models in general to show a trough or ridge in the same general place. However a small change in 50 miles of the 500mb 560 height contour, may matter significantly with downstream sensible wx outcome. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, 40/70 Benchmark said:

Well, I think it will be true here.

We aren't getting a big event imo.

Nor I " ... now, that is preventing the flat wave detonation scenario )," 

I said I was riding the Euro yesterday but I didn't like the 00z run to be honest and pulled the plug this morning myself... 

The fast flow is crippling in this case...too much gradient is keeping these/this open and progressive.  

it's always just a numbers game... either the wave adds enough or not.   if not... next.  the double wave structure with contentious phasing ain't helpin' neither. 

I suppose to be fair this one isn't entirely without hope... there's still 60 hours for this to re ...whatever. But frankly I don't know what we would be re-ing as it's been all over the place. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Ginx snewx said:

Brier scores on the Euro greatly outpace the others. What JSPIN is looking for is sensible wx scores. There is a lot of data online available for review. 

What is a sensible weather score? Inches of snow in your backyard? Because modeled snow is going to be a terrible score. QPF will be bad as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Typhoon Tip said:

Nor I " ... now, that is preventing the flat wave detonation scenario )," 

I said I was riding the Euro yesterday but I didn't like the 00z run to be honest and pulled the plug this morning myself... 

The fast flow is crippling in this case...too much gradient is keeping these/this open and progressive.  

it's always just a numbers game... either the wave adds enough or not.   if not... next.  the double wave structure with contentious phasing ain't helpin' neither. 

I suppose to be fair this one isn't entirely without hope... there's still 60 hours for this to re ...whatever. But frankly I don't know what we would be re-ing as it's been all over the place. 

 

I have never liked more than a couple of inches....still think that is possible, if not likely, despite very paltry 12z euro.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Mr. Windcredible! said:

0-0" here...final call

Dude, hyping with such inflated numbers isn't very responsible as a Meteorologist - if you wanna be taking seriously ... you need to learn to go a bit more conservative when the models signal its time to do so.   

  • Like 1
  • Haha 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 minutes ago, dendrite said:

Scores are higher for cutters!

I know we joke, but that's obviously the perception. Always verify a cutter never a coastal. But I think it proves the point too. The high res guidance can be variable when there is a small window to thread, but you don't notice the shifts when 500 miles can't even save the event for you. But ask someone outside ORD about that same cutter and they will be talking about how much snow changes run to run.

3 minutes ago, Ginx snewx said:

Mslp? 

I mean MSLP isn't great either, but it's also not exactly sensible weather. It does work both ways at times, but generally MSLP is really a response to forcing from aloft. If that's the case you can see how there are just more places for a model to fail before getting to that level.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

While everyone is busy jumping off bridges, perhaps we can look at the lesson here - which is what I was trying to say earlier this morning when everyone was so ecstatic about one or two runs of the Euro that they convinced themselves that Euro is king and GFS sucks, and if Euro says it's going to snow, of course it's going to happen and this was one for SNE not NNE - forgetting that 12 hours earlier, the Euro said we were in the bullseye. It's hard to keep emotions out of the forecast for us weather enthusiasts. One algorithm spits out a few inches of snow and all of the sudden that's DEFINITELY  what's going to happen; someone even said "Euro has been steadfast with this" when if you look back it's bounced more than Pam Anderson in an old episode of BayWatch (I know, dating myself). Then they get worked up because PF, JSping and I "steal people's snow" when in reality, we know it's Diane that does it. And in reality, this is NBD for anyone but if anyone is going to get something, of course chances are it's more likely to happen in NNE than SNE, simply because of climatology - just like a lot more things need to go right for it to snow in DC than SNE. Point is... we all need to chill. 

OK, done with my useless assessment, back to watching this new episode of bridge-jumping on my favorite channel, AmWx.  :popcorn:

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, alex said:

While everyone is busy jumping off bridges, perhaps we can look at the lesson here - which is what I was trying to say earlier this morning when everyone was so ecstatic about one or two runs of the Euro that they convinced themselves that Euro is king and GFS sucks, and if Euro says it's going to snow, of course it's going to happen and this was one for SNE not NNE - forgetting that 12 hours earlier, the Euro said we were in the bullseye. It's hard to keep emotions out of the forecast for us weather enthusiasts. One algorithm spits out a few inches of snow and all of the sudden that's DEFINITELY  what's going to happen; someone even said "Euro has been steadfast with this" when if you look back it's bounced more than Pam Anderson in an old episode of BayWatch (I know, dating myself). Then they get worked up because PF, JSping and I "steal people's snow" when in reality, we know it's Diane that does it. And in reality, this is NBD for anyone but if anyone is going to get something, of course chances are it's more likely to happen in NNE than SNE, simply because of climatology - just like a lot more things need to go right for it to snow in DC than SNE. Point is... we all need to chill. 

OK, done with my useless assessment, back to watching this new episode of bridge-jumping on my favorite channel, AmWx.  :popcorn:

Lol good stuff.  Still time for this to go back to a cutter Alex ha

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, alex said:

While everyone is busy jumping off bridges, perhaps we can look at the lesson here - which is what I was trying to say earlier this morning when everyone was so ecstatic about one or two runs of the Euro that they convinced themselves that Euro is king and GFS sucks, and if Euro says it's going to snow, of course it's going to happen and this was one for SNE not NNE - forgetting that 12 hours earlier, the Euro said we were in the bullseye. It's hard to keep emotions out of the forecast for us weather enthusiasts. One algorithm spits out a few inches of snow and all of the sudden that's DEFINITELY  what's going to happen; someone even said "Euro has been steadfast with this" when if you look back it's bounced more than Pam Anderson in an old episode of BayWatch (I know, dating myself). Then they get worked up because PF, JSping and I "steal people's snow" when in reality, we know it's Diane that does it. And in reality, this is NBD for anyone but if anyone is going to get something, of course chances are it's more likely to happen in NNE than SNE, simply because of climatology - just like a lot more things need to go right for it to snow in DC than SNE. Point is... we all need to chill. 

OK, done with my useless assessment, back to watching this new episode of bridge-jumping on my favorite channel, AmWx.  :popcorn:

Bold is the only lesson in this... just imho - 

In a philosophical twist though, the GFS was the best model - if things go on to be the lame ass showing as it looks to be...  Because why?  regardless of how we get there, that shit panache has been jammed down our throats by the GFS the whole way... Maybe it doesn't get points for consistency in butt bangin', but for the essence of the act its self?  it's been servicing inches far more consistently and prodigiously than this thing appears destined to snow.  

almost funny -

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Damage In Tolland said:

As in not even 1-3?

It's not a black and white. There is a chance of 1-3" but it's not a good chance. Straight EPS is like 30% for 1+ and 10% for 3+.

I think my forecast at the moment would be sub-advisory, and if we have to work up from there we can.

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, CoastalWx said:

This whole thing was so marginal to begin with, and it’s not like the euro dropped 18 to 24 inches only to bring it back down to 2 inches.

Well, to be fair, it also had a pretty significant impact, especially south as of 6z. This isn’t 150 hours out... it doesn’t need to go from 24” to 2”.

Sensible weather is completely different for a system 2-3 days out. That’s a fail in my book. Calling a spade a spade 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, TauntonBlizzard2013 said:

Well, to be fair, it also had a pretty significant impact, especially south as of 6z. This isn’t 150 hours out... it doesn’t need to go from 24” to 2”.

Sensible weather is completely different for a system 2-3 days out. That’s a fail in my book. Calling a spade a spade 

Even on the EPS it was low on 3” probs. The clown maps were too generous as well. Throwing snow down with temps above 0C at 925. Meh. You had a garbage airmass to start and we’re relying on dynamics to cool it. You know how that goes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...