Attention All NYC Subforum Members

[JC-CT]

If you cant comment on the eastern days, then saying the argument is weak is well...weak. And if we cant get people over the impenetrable wall that is subforums to share or read thoughts, then repetitive pattern threads arent an issue. Because they arent repetitive.

I do read them in multiple subs, and they are repetitive. I think I get your point which is that the threads would be cluttered and would require a higher level of moderation, and I don't necessarily disagree. But my climate is more similar to NYC than NNE, but I share a subforum with NNE without any issues whatsoever. You haven't made a convincing argument that climate differences alone along the i95 corridor represent a significant barrier.

[HailMan06]

Could go by forecast office because people are bickering over region. If you're under the same office clearly you're in the same region.

I'm in Mt.Holly's region but well within NY's metro region. My area is much more closely aligned with NYC than Philly geographically and culturally speaking.

[Brian5671]

I do read them in multiple subs, and they are repetitive. I think I get your point which is that the threads would be cluttered and would require a higher level of moderation, and I don't necessarily disagree. But my climate is more similar to NYC than NNE, but I share a subforum with NNE without any issues whatsoever. You haven't made a convincing argument that climate differences alone along the i95 corridor represent a significant barrier.

yes, but not that many live in NNE.   So it works.  You are talking about combining areas with large amounts of posters...apples and oranges here

[BxEngine]

I do read them in multiple subs, and they are repetitive. I think I get your point which is that the threads would be cluttered and would require a higher level of moderation, and I don't necessarily disagree. But my climate is more similar to NYC than NNE, but I share a subforum with NNE without any issues whatsoever. You haven't made a convincing argument that climate differences alone along the i95 corridor represent a significant barrier.

I havent made that argument at all, because that isnt my argument. It was only in reference to "pattern threads".

[rygar]

Totally agree on "Northeast"

[JC-CT]

I havent made that argument at all, because that isnt my argument. It was only in reference to "pattern threads".

I read between the lines of your "good pattern for Maine is a good pattern for Philly" as a sarcastic way of making that argument. I apologize if I misunderstood.

[BxEngine]

I do read them in multiple subs, and they are repetitive. I think I get your point which is that the threads would be cluttered and would require a higher level of moderation, and I don't necessarily disagree. But my climate is more similar to NYC than NNE, but I share a subforum with NNE without any issues whatsoever. You haven't made a convincing argument that climate differences alone along the i95 corridor represent a significant barrier.

And moderation is very low on my list of concerns, ill happily ban people who cant control themselves. Our threads in nyc move fast even when everyone is behaving, as does the NE forum. Having to skim through more than double the amount of posts to find info from coastal or will isnt efficient and would push people away instead of being willing participants.

[WeatherFox]

I'm in Mt.Holly's region but well within NY's metro region. My area is much much more closely aligned with NYC than Philly geographically and culturally speaking.

Your in the best of two worlds, can blend the analysis and forecasts between your two NWS offices.

[forkyfork]

get bastardi to post here himself-he posts on the other board

i'll post on his behalf right now:

blah blah not 1998 blah blah 2010/2003/1958 blah blah cherry picked coldest ensemble mean

[BxEngine]

I read between the lines of your "good pattern for Maine is a good pattern for Philly" as a sarcastic way of making that argument. I apologize if I misunderstood.

It was sarcastic in reference to a single pattern thread instead of pattern threads for regions.

[LongBeachSurfFreak]

Yes, we need a bar trip, who's in?

I am for sure as long as it in the city

[IrishRob17]

I am for sure as long as it in the city

There are many cities in our sub-forum...

[Brian5671]

i'll post on his behalf right now:

blah blah not 1998 blah blah 2010/2003/1958 blah blah cherry picked coldest ensemble mean

[JerseyWx]

I say we go into sub forums based on radio stations. Maybe something like If you get the Hudson Valley stations to come in clear you go to that forum, or if you get the NYC stations clearly, you're in another sub forum.

[wthrmn654]

I say we go into sub forums based on radio stations. Maybe something like If you get the Hudson Valley stations to come in clear you go to that forum, or if you get the NYC stations clearly, you're in another sub forum.

Oh jeez now that's great crazy!

[JerseyWx]

Oh jeez now that's great crazy!

Want to be in a sub forum you can't get to come in clearly or hear? Get a bigger Antenna!

[Brian5671]

I say we go into sub forums based on radio stations. Maybe something like If you get the Hudson Valley stations to come in clear you go to that forum, or if you get the NYC stations clearly, you're in another sub forum.

I'd be in 3 subforums then!  LOL

[JerseyWx]

I'd be in 3 subforums then! LOL

Hey, whatever works! I'd be in Hudson and NYC forums too

[cut]

Another option could just be an event based system - the heck with locations. We all lurk on other areas forums anyway. I know a lot of us head to the New England thread quite often - of course there seems to be more restraint on bickering in that forum which helps it be a readable forum.

[LongBeachSurfFreak]

There are many cities in our sub-forum...

That one called New York. I hear it has a few bars and it just happens to be directly between you and I. Oh and the rest of the forum too. Funny how that works so well

[Cfa]

I say we go into sub forums based on radio stations. Maybe something like If you get the Hudson Valley stations to come in clear you go to that forum, or if you get the NYC stations clearly, you're in another sub forum.

Central/Eastern Long Island would need its own sub forum. NYC stations are pretty much nonexistent for me, CT stations are full of static as well. Long Island's 106.1 BLI (pop music) is the only clear station I know of, it really feels like I live in the middle of the ocean sometimes lol. My phone serves as my radio station.

[JerseyWx]

Central/Eastern Long Island would need its own sub forum. NYC stations are pretty much nonexistent for me, CT stations are full of static as well. Long Island's 106.1 BLI (pop music) is the only clear station I know of, it really feels like I live in the middle of the ocean sometimes lol. My phone serves as my radio station.

I was only kidding. That would be pretty funny though. With iHeart Radio, that system could be gotten around too. Surprised you can't get NYC stations though, they really put out.

[NEG NAO]

IMO the forums should be renamed the Mount Holly Forecast Zones Forum and The Upton Forecast Zones Forum to coordinate with with the NWS. In the description of the forums all counties will be listed that are to be discussed. Every other sub forum in this web site should be renamed also.

[CIK62]

I think if server capacity allows, the forums should stay just as they are  and permission given  to the blogger to have his/her blog entry appear as a 'duplicate' in say the Mount Holly sub-forum or Nassau County  or SW Conn. etc.---as they deem appropriate..    

Members/guests who want to concentrate on just one forum or the main one as it is now will have that option, and not have to weave through all the material.

Many members/guests have family/friends in nearby areas or travel there so might be of value, again if capacity allows.

[IsentropicLift]

Could go by forecast office because people are bickering over region. If you're under the same office clearly you're in the same region.

I'm in the Mt Holly CWA yet I live roughly 25 miles West of NYC, closer than most of LI.

[IsentropicLift]

IMO the forums should be renamed the Mount Holly Forecast Zones Forum and The Upton Forecast Zones Forum to coordinate with with the NWS. In the description of the forums all counties will be listed that are to be discussed. Every other sub forum in this web site should be renamed also.

Monmouth is Mt Holly and it borders NYC.

[NEG NAO]

Monmouth is Mt Holly and it borders NYC.

You are correct - for the category New Jersey Counties in the Mount Holly Zone bordering NYC to the south for $ 500

[Brian5671]

Monmouth is Mt Holly and it borders NYC.

yeah for some that would not work.  CT is broken up into 3  NWS offices believe it or not.

[NEG NAO]

Coordinating forums with the NWS zones offices would also make this web site appear more professional IMO....Also just naming the forums Northeast is a big mistake because it will just add to the confusion and cause more bickering....

[UnionWeatherWx]

Monmouth is Mt Holly and it borders NYC.

Same with Middlessex, and Southern/Central Union county, wouldn't work tbh.