Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,609
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    Chargers10
    Newest Member
    Chargers10
    Joined

Feb 25-26 Discussion/pbp


Wow

Recommended Posts

I've picked up another 1/2 inch of snow in the past hour in southern wake! big flakes!!!

I think this helps keeps temp cool for tomorrow! It is the missing piece of the puzzle!

Unfortunately, it won't help with the mid levels. If you want to see mainly snow, you'd better hope the models hold steady and then keep your fingers crossed...or tick south and you can breathe a bit easier. Another north tick and it's going to be pretty much game over for significant accums.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 3.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

With the exception of the NAM the 850 low appears weak or open enough to me that strong precip rates can overcome its track, the 0C line is close but the other thing I noticed is there is massive room for evaporative cooling in the 800-900-mb layer...the big difference between the NAM and GFS is the NAM has screaming SW flow and WAA from 800-850mb over Ga, the GFS and most other guidance does not, its all 700-780mb where its easily cold enough to stay below 0C.  If the NAM is wrong on that 800-850 idea there will be massive busts in south Atlanta.  The new GFS cannot be trusted thermally in the 1000-850 layer, its got serious issues being too warm.

I see it so much where I am.  It almost like you can see the roulette wheel slowing down over head, and the column getting colder, or not, depending on where the marble stops, lol.  All my life I've seen lines drawn, when I live in Atl, and down here, but the final placement often  comes down to action time. This seems like some good cold, and the battle with the waa, especially if the storm is weaker, will be interesting.  I'll be watching Alabama to see what I'm getting, not plumes, and maps :)  Lookouts soundings will be all important now.

 Poor Atl mets.  I've watched 'em bust all my life, 'cause, of course, you remember the busts, lol, but it's a thankless job predicting snow in Ga. because the tolerances are often so tight. And the column does what it wants, not what drawn lines say it has to do.  Tony

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It hasn't really shifted north, the temps are just be modeled a bit warmer which may or may not be correct.  Northern counties in the upstate should be fine.

When you say Northern counties, are you talking above 85 or the mountains of South Carolina? Also, I have not been able to look at the models much today but are the 850's getting warmer or the surface? I think the models are running about 4 degrees too warm for this system, as stated above by another Met. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

When you say Northern counties, are you talking above 85 or the mountains of South Carolina? Also, I have not been able to look at the models much today but are the 850's getting warmer or the surface? I think the models are running about 4 degrees too warm for this system, as stated above by another Met.

I can tell you based on what most everything shows, North of 85 in greenville, pickens, oconee counties gets hammered! Possibly 5+
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looking at the cross section temp profile of the NAM below for KCLT, this goes from rain to snow to maybe rain to snow. 540 is not valuable at all here? Never heard that one before. 

temp.png

Tons of research by Keeter et all showing value of partial thickness values vs 1000-500mb thickness values in this area. I have hardly ever used 1000-500mb thickness here in 2 decades of forecasting

Link to comment
Share on other sites

NC or SC?

Folks generally don't get blasted for observations, as long as they have some modeling or synoptic support. Now if you said "Looks like this one is toast! This sucks!" without at least citing support, you'd be begging for banishment to banter-land.

 

Opinion supported by observation leads to better discussion.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Folks generally don't get blasted for observations, as long as they have some modeling or synoptic support. Now if you said "Looks like this one is toast! This sucks!" without at least citing support, you'd be begging for banishment to banter-land.

 

Opinion supported by observation leads to better discussion.

 

That's the key here. It has about as much synoptic support as you can ask for. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Because they are not when I open them. They open as a oversized image so zoomed that I can't even see the entire image. That's what I was asking if they were truly gifs or maybe screen shots of a gif, idk why a gif would not be working when I open it.

Sometimes a GIF is just an image, the ones that move are animated GIFs. All is well on your phone!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nothing wrong with some legitimate skepticism. This is not a slam dunk for Raleigh or Charlotte, especially if you at all factor in the trends over the last 24 hours. Yay we have a potential snowstorm on our doorstep. But being somewhat skeptical, with good reason, is not any different than being overly optimistic that you're going to get six inches of snow. No reason for anybody to get mad about either view. Just discuss it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Still think all of Metro ATL gets all rain, only far northern burbs have any shot at accumulations. WSI RPM ("futurecast" on TV stations), SREF, NAM, GFS all screw us- and we are now less than 24 hours away. The fat lady has sung. Congrats far north GA, you will get nailed, down here another hose job.

 

Ouch, but I can't help but take the northern trend overall today seriously. I know you tend to be a bit pessimistic (or realistic) but this is looking like a far north GA special (Rome-Gainesville north).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nothing wrong with some legitimate skepticism. This is not a slam dunk for Raleigh or Charlotte, especially if you at all factor in the trends over the last 24 hours. Yay we have a potential snowstorm on our doorstep. But being somewhat skeptical, with good reason, is not any different than being overly optimistic that you're going to get six inches of snow. No reason for anybody to get mad about either view. Just discuss it.

 

Agreed, the QPF jackpot is toeing the line with mid level temps, it's going to be sick gradient tomorrow night with rain/snow, heavy snow v/s light snow all within 30-50 miles of each other. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I remember being right on the edge in 2011...The rain/snow line was around where the Atlanta  airport was, I feel like it's going to set up right around the airport again, if not further north(maybe south if 850s are wrong). Still ended up with 5-6 inches from that storm though because of the initial frontogenetic band that centered on downtown Atlanta.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Larry, if you see this...what's the correlation between the wind speeds.  I've got wsw at 9mph during part of the inch of precip. With the 3 meter at 2 from the north, and at 925 I've got 7 from the north east.  Does your charting say anything about the optimal cold air feed, and strength opposing the wsw feed of waa and moisture.  We've got the track, the wsw feed,  cold air,  heavy rates expected.  Does the speed play  big a part on your maps of a typical storm as does  the direction?  T

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nothing wrong with some legitimate skepticism. This is not a slam dunk for Raleigh or Charlotte, especially if you at all factor in the trends over the last 24 hours. Yay we have a potential snowstorm on our doorstep. But being somewhat skeptical, with good reason, is not any different than being overly optimistic that you're going to get six inches of snow. No reason for anybody to get mad about either view. Just discuss it.

It is almost always marginal temp wise these cold events the last couple of seasons are less common

The thing is being near the area where the warm nose is formidable but not out of control is very often the place where the highest snow totals are.

95% of model data is all snow for RDU so I feel things are looking good for the Triangle. I think the NW trends have stopped, the more reasonable bad scenario to me is a flatter scenario with less qpf less dynamics less dynamical cooling and thus the somewhat marginal boundary layer temps take longer to be overcome.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

alright folks...enough off topic banter stuff. I'm getting a little tired of deleting posts that have no value whatsoever in regards to this thread. If you want to complain about getting screwed, talk about tv mets, or make jokes..do so in the banter thread and leave this thread to actual model analysis. Otherwise there will be some timeouts coming.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This was posted December 24th 2010....

 

 

 

Looking at soundings for RDU, it is too warm at 18z for any snow Saturday afternoon but the profile cools quickly so snow will be supported by 00z Sunday. The issue therafter is saturation is decreasing rapidly as you head into the next several hours and it may switch back over to rain if this were to occur. 

 

All of our good storms are borderline and most good storms it seems to be the same concern but the majority of the time synoptics win out. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It is almost always marginal temp wise these cold events the last couple of seasons are less common

The thing is being near the area where the warm nose is formidable but not out of control is very often the place where the highest snow totals are.

95% of model data is all snow for RDU so I feel things are looking good for the Triangle. I think the NW trends have stopped, the more reasonable bad scenario to me is a flatter scenario with less qpf less dynamics less dynamical cooling and thus the somewhat marginal boundary layer temps take longer to be overcome.

Thanks for posting this. That helps frame some of my concerns in the right context.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Our local ch 4 met still has a swath of 4-7" basically about 25 miles either side of 85!

The radar he showed had the finger of rain streaking ahead of the storm and near or east of ATL by around noon and here by 5 as rain! I think BL temps will matter, if we get to high of 47 as forecast , that will be a problem. Get clouds in here early and drop some temps tonight, and we will be good!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...