Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,588
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    LopezElliana
    Newest Member
    LopezElliana
    Joined

Winter 2014-2015 Pattern Discussion Thread II


JoshM

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 2.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Is the Euro EPS just the ENS? I was under the impression that the EPS was just kind of a ENS Mean but just one run to represent it?

The EPS control is the Euro OP run at a lower resolution, used to then run the ensemble suite. I think the term EPS is also used to describe the entire ensemble suite...that's probably a misuse of the term.

Edit: I might be wrong on the term EPS. I was thinking it referred to the entire Euro model system, not just the ENS. Might be wrong though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I was going to say the same thing. Over NA it's been terrible.

Yeah I mean it depends on what you're looking at....mslp tracks, energy, 850mb, 500mb, ground temps, etc. Especially in your backyard. Not as simple as a model picking up a storm...maybe the GFS will rule in the next 10 day period who knows. Euro still looks better in most areas based on this direct comparison website over NA http://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/gmb/STATS_vsdb/ but I'm no met so I digress.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i agree with this its not like the euro cutting the low is wrong it's the fact the model itself is haveing trouble with the pattern!

Arguing the physics of a model is denialisim 101. If the model cuts a low it's certainly possible if the depiction it shows with all the other features verifies, End of story. This line of thinking is anti science.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah I mean it depends on what you're looking at....mslp tracks, energy, 850mb, 500mb, ground temps, etc. Especially in your backyard. Not as simple as a model picking up a storm...maybe the GFS will rule in the next 10 day period who knows. Euro still looks better in most areas based on this direct comparison website over NA http://www.emc.ncep.noaa.gov/gmb/STATS_vsdb/ but I'm no met so I digress.

Didn't JB and RMaue argue about this last week, Euro v/s GFS day 10. I need to dig it up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What is it about the Euro that made no sense? You could make the case that at 192, it is once again trying to dig energy into the SW. But I don't see any reason at all why the energy couldn't cut. We have no -NAO, no 50/50 and a PV way up in Canada. I don't see why it should stay suppressed, unless the pattern is completely wrong as shown (which it could be).

We hear a lot through the winter about "no way this or that could cut", but there really has to be a reason for that. A big block with a 50/50 and strong confluence, pressing and not lifting would keep it suppressed. We often see these features lifting out, and if that's the case, then you bet things can cut. The GFS shows a pretty good depiction of a pattern where you wouldn't expect something to cut.

 

Agree Cold Rain, good points.  The modeled -NAO is looking like a big fail.  On the other hand, the favorable western ridging looks like it will get us in the conversation as we start the new year.  The 01/01 storm on the 12z GFS was the spitting image of the late Jan '14 storm...a weak wave riding up an arctic boundary that has pressed way south.

 

The models have been quite inconsistent of late, including the ensembles.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cold rain IMO the EURO could be right, but I am saying lets hold off, for now.  It has been over amplifying the energy and has caused things to want to show them cutting.  Yesterdays storm was prime example of how it was trying to be much stronger than it turned out.  The KING is still the EURO, and it could be right..we could be looking at a cutter next weekend and for NYD..I fully agree with you.  I am saying, until I See other things that strong, I won't go all in on it, because lately it has been all over the place and has over did the phasing of the streams.  Can we all agree on that?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cold rain IMO the EURO could be right, but I am saying lets hold off, for now. It has been over amplifying the energy and has caused things to want to show them cutting. Yesterdays storm was prime example of how it was trying to be much stronger than it turned out. The KING is still the EURO, and it could be right..we could be looking at a cutter next weekend and for NYD..I fully agree with you. I am saying, until I See other things that strong, I won't go all in on it, because lately it has been all over the place and has over did the phasing of the streams. Can we all agree on that?

Totally. You're saying that the wound up solution is likely to be wrong because of the Euro's tendency to amp things up. I gotcha and I agree. Until we see agreement across the board inside 3 or 4 days, we won't know which is right.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think the two models are that far apart days 7-10.

GFS is deeper with the trough and the Euro is lagging a little but both have the same idea.Actually I think the Euro trended toward the GFS a little today.

Just my opinion.

How's the solar flux stuff and strat stuff coming along? Any good news?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agree Cold Rain, good points.  The modeled -NAO is looking like a big fail.  On the other hand, the favorable western ridging looks like it will get us in the conversation as we start the new year.  The 01/01 storm on the 12z GFS was the spitting image of the late Jan '14 storm...a weak wave riding up an arctic boundary that has pressed way south.

 

The models have been quite inconsistent of late, including the ensembles.

Agreed, the GEFS is a great look but the EPS doesn't agree, I don't know which one is right.  If the EPS was showing what we wanted and the GEFS wasn't we would be all hugging the GEFS.  Pretty big differences at day 9 with trough placement and the EPS doesn't budge east through the end of the run, it's been consistent with this.

 

Oh yeah, with the blocking going poof there is a good chance the first half of the winter will average a +AO.  I guess we do need that SSW for a -AO after all.

post-2311-0-21745200-1419199764_thumb.pn

post-2311-0-99929100-1419199764_thumb.pn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The EPS control is the Euro OP run at a lower resolution, used to then run the ensemble suite. I think the term EPS is also used to describe the entire ensemble suite...that's probably a misuse of the term.

Edit: I might be wrong on the term EPS. I was thinking it referred to the entire Euro model system, not just the ENS. Might be wrong though.

EPS stands for Ensemble Prediction System. The Integrated Forecast System (what we know as the Euro) has both a deterministic and an ensemble (the EPS) component.

In the same way, the GFS ensembles are known as the GEFS (Global Ensemble Forecast System).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

bull, the facts are i don't hug one model! I look at what makes sense ? I must be right the eps has no cutting low an is much cooler looking over all . models have bad runs this one had one today !

The cutting solution may or may not be right. My point is people are way to quick to say a model is wrong when it doesn't show the solution they want, a cutting low is a very real possibility. For some to say it's not possible are in denial. The Euro could have it nailed, the model obviously says the cutting solution is a possibility. Also try and use better English if you can, sometimes your posts are almost unreadable.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Borderline solar max conditions still,had a huge X-flare yesterday though.Just watching if it effects the -QBO or not.

Zonal winds still forecasted to slow,think the PV will be under attack with the strong -EPO working on it.

Good deal. Thanks and please keep us posted since you're our resident expert!

And thanks James for the EPS definition.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agreed, the GEFS is a great look but the EPS doesn't agree, I don't know which one is right. If the EPS was showing what we wanted and the GEFS wasn't we would be all hugging the GEFS. Pretty big differences at day 9 with trough placement and the EPS doesn't budge east through the end of the run, it's been consistent with this.

Oh yeah, with the blocking going poof there is a good chance the first half of the winter will average a +AO. I guess we do need that SSW for a -AO after all.

I'm pretty sure we could get a wintry storm with either of those maps, I'll take those looks!
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Agreed, the GEFS is a great look but the EPS doesn't agree, I don't know which one is right.  If the EPS was showing what we wanted and the GEFS wasn't we would be all hugging the GEFS.  Pretty big differences at day 9 with trough placement and the EPS doesn't budge east through the end of the run, it's been consistent with this.

 

Oh yeah, with the blocking going poof there is a good chance the first half of the winter will average a +AO.  I guess we do need that SSW for a -AO after all.

That GEFS image looks like dry cold to me. The Euro is more conducive for actual winter storms, although it is just a bit too far west with the mean trough.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

That GEFS image looks like dry cold to me. The Euro is more conducive for actual winter storms, although it is just a bit too far west with the mean trough.

 

I was going to say if you blend the GEFS and EPS you have something really good, IMO.  But that is total wish casting by me....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

GFS looks interesting around Jan 1st. The pattern starts to get into a position that could support a storm. will be fun to watch the pattern change over the next week.

That's the one I like :)  The rain has started to run underneath, and some has made it up here, which is always the first tell for me.  And it hasn't been 65 and rain...seldom is in winter.  Follow the rain in winter, and the cold will come around, most times, I think. Rain every day, or three, usually finds some cold to play with, even if it's 36 and rain down here.

 

 (PS....Larry took climo over my 30 or 40 years of questionable memory about this...choosing to go with over 100 years of climo on the matter, lol. but one of these days I'll be right, and then I'll go na, na, nana na at him, and his wet/frozen climo ice cream :)  And anyway, climo for around the 1st, in Ga. is propitious :) At least where I've been living.  After Xmas day, the play begins in Ga.  Tony

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...