Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,608
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    NH8550
    Newest Member
    NH8550
    Joined

Winter 2014-2015 Pattern Discussion Thread II


JoshM

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 2.1k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Has anybody ever looked up how many measurable snows in December the last 10 years

Nah....it's too easy to whip out the ol' "December isn't a snow month" line. Personally, I haven't researched how many winter events happen in December vs JFM, and frankly, I don't care all that much. December is a month when you can realistically expect shots of cold and opportunities for storms, especially the last couple of weeks. To go through the month without either is a fail. There's really not much other way to look at it.

And I don't really much like the metaphor about punting a month or sacrificing December for January or whatever. I mean, I understand the sentiment and all, but it's not like any mental conclusion we come to accept has any bearing on what the weather actually does, kind of like what Widre was saying. I don't punt or kick field goals or kick extra points. It's 4 down territory all winter long. It's an onsides kick and go for two after a score, every. single. time.

We only have about 12-14 weeks or so to realistically expect snow. I realize we live in the SE and we're going to waste some prime winter time by dealing with bad patterns. But every week that goes by with nothing to show for it is a significant enough percentage of our overall winter to matter to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pack,

 I guess we're largely in agreement. I was just looking back at past CFSv2 winter month by month forecasts (so the horrible Nov. 2014 not included) out 8 days before the month being forecasted (will be 12/24 in this case) for the SE:

 

Dec. 2011: predicted normal; was warm; grade C

Jan 2012: warm predicted and verified: A

Feb, 2012: warm predicted and verified: A

Dec. 2012: predicted slightly warm and verified as solid warmth: B

Jan 2013: predicted cool and was very warm: F

Feb 2013: predicted cold and was cool: B

Dec, 2013: predicted cool and was mild: D

Jan 2014: predicted cool and was very cold: B

Feb 2014: predicted cool and was near norm: B

Dec 2014: predicted and will verify mild: A

 

 AVG from 8 days out: B...not as bad as I had earlier assumed. Any average better than C suggests some skill. Out of these 10 forecasts, a respectable 7 were good to excellent and only 2 busted. Conclusion: Having the CFSv2 8 day forecast for the next winter month on the side of cold would not be a bad thing. Let's see how it is on 12/24.

Yep, agree. When you take it FWIW it's pretty good.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nah....it's too easy to whip out the ol' "December isn't a snow month" line. Personally, I haven't researched how many winter events happen in December vs JFM, and frankly, I don't care all that much. December is a month when you can realistically expect shots of cold and opportunities for storms, especially the last couple of weeks. To go through the month without either is a fail. There's really not much other way to look at it.

And I don't really much like the metaphor about punting a month or sacrificing December for January or whatever. I mean, I understand the sentiment and all, but it's not like any mental conclusion we come to accept has any bearing on what the weather actually does, kind of like what Widre was saying. I don't punt or kick field goals or kick extra points. It's 4 down territory all winter long. It's an onsides kick and go for two after a score, every. single. time.

We only have about 12-14 weeks or so to realistically expect snow. I realize we live in the SE and we're going to waste some prime winter time by dealing with bad patterns. But every week that goes by with nothing to show for it is a significant enough percentage of our overall winter to matter to me.

isn't Raleigh running slightly below average for the month?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Fwiw, today's CFSv2 2M forecast for Jan warmed back a lot to just a little cooler than normal overall for the SE. To remind folks, yesterday's had a whopping 5-7 colder than normal and the coldest on the planet in the SE US. As we get closer to Jan., I'll be following these more closely as I do think they have some value as the subsequent month approaches.

 

http://www.cpc.ncep.noaa.gov/products/people/mchen/CFSv2FCST/monthly/images/CFSv2.NaT2m.20141221.201501.gif

I agree. Although comparing the last 3 runs vs this run it seems a little off in the big picture.

 

Last 3 runs averaged have two distinct couplets trough, ridge, trough, ridge, trough.

l2zQehn.png

 

This run still has a slight southern trough but it seems to be off. The PNA seems to have shifted east, and there would definitely be a bigger trough on the east between those two ridges, IMO. It could help that they're averaged runs, though. The 14 day average is almost the same as the top picture FWIW, hopefully it's not a trend killing the trough but I doubt it personally.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think December is a realistic month for snow/Ice chances.... JMO   And like some have already said every week that passes is a week gone not to make up.......... So I disagree that you just throw December out and start looking for snow/cold in January..... 3 months folks Dec-Feb and we already lost Dec. I know we have snows in March BIG deal it's 60 the next day and Muddy as all get out. We just lost one month of winter!!! JMO

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nah....it's too easy to whip out the ol' "December isn't a snow month" line. Personally, I haven't researched how many winter events happen in December vs JFM, and frankly, I don't care all that much. December is a month when you can realistically expect shots of cold and opportunities for storms, especially the last couple of weeks. To go through the month without either is a fail. There's really not much other way to look at it.

And I don't really much like the metaphor about punting a month or sacrificing December for January or whatever. I mean, I understand the sentiment and all, but it's not like any mental conclusion we come to accept has any bearing on what the weather actually does, kind of like what Widre was saying. I don't punt or kick field goals or kick extra points. It's 4 down territory all winter long. It's an onsides kick and go for two after a score, every. single. time.

We only have about 12-14 weeks or so to realistically expect snow. I realize we live in the SE and we're going to waste some prime winter time by dealing with bad patterns. But every week that goes by with nothing to show for it is a significant enough percentage of our overall winter to matter to me.

 

You come live down here in Atlanta during December and you'll see how well both of the bolded statements will be jeopardized once tested lol. I can only think of two Decembers within the past 15 years where there's been measurable snow. (2000 and 2010) Maybe I'm forgetting a year or two, but that's about it.

 

Although I do agree with everything else and especially that December realistically can be a month to produce, it just hasn't done it for us. :lol:

 

In the end it doesn't really matter, I personally still feel great about the potential for a wintry threat a week from now going into the new year.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I noticed how by hour 126 the same potential system, not as strong or as much energy as the Christmas one is showing again.  Notice how the streams are separating.  I am ok with, because it should drive the cold front through, and if there is enough southern branch *if you will* energy it should spark something next Sunday.  Lets see where it goes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 The 0Z GFS is coming in warmer and with a less impressive and more offshore western ridge to this point. Hopefully this doesn't mean it will come in warmer for later in the run though I'm honestly a bit suspicious that may happen.

 

UGLY looking run to this point. :(

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chris, yeah the ridging on both sides has taken a hike relative to earlier GFS runs. I have a feeling that the masses here are not going to like how the rest of this run looks, but let's see how it plays out..after all, I do believe in miracles and there are still another nine days in the run lmao. Also, it is just one run. It can always be discarded. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chris, yeah the ridging on both sides has taken a hike relative to earlier GFS runs. I have a feeling that the masses here are not going to like how the rest of this run looks, but let's see how it plays out..after all, I do believe in miracles and there are still another nine days in the run lmao. Also, it is just one run. It can always be discarded. ;)

LOL very true.  Amazing how things change from runs to run.  Did the ENS look ok?  I don't remember 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wait a minute! Is this really the same model?? The differences from just the 18Z are absolutely astounding!

 

Did the Para take over??

 

This is friggin bizarre!

 

Edit: In all of my years of following the GFS, this has to be one of the largest changes I've ever seen in just one run for the 6-10+ forecast!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wait a minute! Is this really the same model?? The differences from just the 18Z are absolutely astounding!

 

Did the Para take over??

 

This is friggin bizarre!

 

Edit: In all of my years of following the GFS, this has to be one of the largest changes I've ever seen in just one run for the 6-10+ forecast!

I agree.  This run is so frickin drastic, its hard to believe in to be honest.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...