Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,587
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    LopezElliana
    Newest Member
    LopezElliana
    Joined

Winter 2013 - 2014 Banter Thread


NEG NAO

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

It's 18 degrees out. The reason the models make mistakes about storms isn't because "it's becoming spring."

 

Almost frightening to listen to the dribble you espouse.

Right, and it's it going to be near 60 in 48 hours. Pretty typical March. If you would actually read what I post, I have already mentioned that the chances of us getting through March without at least a bit more snow seem low. However, those looking for blockbuster storms as we get to the middle of the month will almost always come out empty handed or at the very least dissatisfied.

All of the calculations made by models are predicated on existing, current conditions. Given the volatile nature of the month, small errors that normally would be multiplied exponentially due to the non-linear aspect of the atmosphere (in terms of calculating future conditions) are magnified significantly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He said today the March sun will make it okay, nothing okay about 18 degrees.

Why does he post about his humid tropical area of VA so much? We get it they radiate well and so does Atlanta! No way in hell would I want to live there if i was a snow lover. Would choose NYC over Atl and sw VA every time

Where I grew up we average around 35" of snow a year, so more than here. Parts of SW VA get over 60" because of upslope snow.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Did NYC get below 0? Did we set daily or monthly records?

No to the below 0, and one daily low max. We have been below normal for the entire winter. Bdr,JFK, lga, ewr have all set records of some type this winter. You have continue to be wrong on the strength on the cold air all year. That artic blast in January you said would be nothing special, yet NYC was 3 at 10am. You also said NYC would not get to a single digit low at the end February wrong!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Where I grew up we average around 35" of snow a year, so more than here. Parts of SW VA get over 60" because of upslope snow.

Okay parts of northern jersey are over that and so is sw ct. Would never want to live down there for snow, and the summers are absolutely nasty. We get that u did well in 93 woohoo!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could subdivide climate any number of which ways due to local effects-for example, two counties in PA which are literally next to each other (Somerset and Bedford) have 30" and 160" snow averages respectively in places because of terrain effects. Lake effect snow belts have numerous shaft vs. bonanza spots. But no one would say that NYC has a similar climate to Jacksonville, FL or New Orleans, and a different one than Boston, who we are beating this year in snowfall and have beaten twice more in the past decade. That's just completely foolish.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No to the below 0, and one daily low max. We have been below normal for the entire winter. Bdr,JFK, lga, ewr have all set records of some type this winter. You have continue to be wrong on the strength on the cold air all year. That artic blast in January you said would be nothing special, yet NYC was 3 at 10am. You also said NYC would not get to a single digit low at the end February wrong!

He's not the only one who busted on the late Feb cold, so did I. The heat island really is a major contributor to warmth in the urban areas.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could subdivide climate any number of which ways due to local effects-for example, two counties in PA which are literally next to each other (Somerset and Bedford) have 30" and 160" snow averages respectively in places because of terrain effects. Lake effect snow belts have numerous shaft vs. bonanza spots. But no one would say that NYC has a similar climate to Jacksonville, FL or New Orleans, and a different one than Boston, who we are beating this year in snowfall and have beaten twice more in the past decade. That's just completely foolish.

I certainly see your point here and obviously we don't have the same climate as the Gulf Coast. I don't think anyone here is arguing that we have the same exact climate as the Gulf Coast but the fact remains that under Köppen we fall under the same climate classification. We can have a separate discussion on how the subtropical climate is defined since IMO would be more productive to discuss.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

And the ones insulting my intelligence would be exempt? If people want to come out firing, they better be able to take the response.

the first person who wrote a personal attack should be suspended  - the proper way to handle the situation is to report the person and not reply - the moderators should be doing their jobs......IMO have to clean up dodge before the next busy season - to help restore the reputation of this forum and make it a fun place to come too not a stress event........

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The growing season at places like LGA or some other stations may in fact be 240 days...not that different from Norfolk, VA...but again...is a local artificially modified climate supposed to cause a misunderstanding of the climate of the overall region?

 

It is very significant if you are going to plow under a runway and plant cotton.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think people understand what climo means

They don't, they ignore the pattern and just use the law of averages basically. If climo were always right then NYC would be seeing about 25-30" instead of nearly 60", places like Chicago and Detroit would be much warmer and far less snowy this winter than they are if the climo argument kept getting thrown out there. What about on the opposite site of that spectrum with winter like 2001-2002 and 2011-2012, what about using climo then. 

 

How about the extremely anomalous warmth of March 2012 or storms like Sandy. To me it's about the pattern in place then just basic climo, sure using climo in March yields higher temperatures than January in general but during anomalous events, you can't always bet on climo. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

i think this is more like a 36 to 42 inch snowfall. we're long overdue for the 1 in 350 year event. and the canadian has been hinting at just such an event (on and off) for the last 30 years.... and now we're just about inside 4 days.

Sorry for asking for such specifics.....but do you know which areas will get the higher amounts of 42"? Not that I'd be unhappy with 36", but of course I'd rather get the higher amounts!!

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No way-none of us have a subtropical climate. Would you honestly say that anywhere near Long Island has a similar climate to places like New Orleans or even the VA Tidewater, where palm trees grow naturally? Those areas are considered subtropical too. Tropical is south of Tampa, FL.

I was kinda stirring the pot. Obviously the lb overall temps are similar to the rest of li.

I think a better measure would be to use hardiness zones.

A place like laurel hollow or the pine barrens are going to be a zone lower then lb and NYC. The coldest temps in lb/NYC during the last decade have been around zero. Out and up there it's more like -15. That has an effect on what can and can't grow in a given area.

The southern magnolia comment is valid. In an urban sheltered environment the tree made it through some serious cold. IMO It wouldn't stand a chance out in the pine barrens (not accounting for soil differences)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

No to the below 0, and one daily low max. We have been below normal for the entire winter. Bdr,JFK, lga, ewr have all set records of some type this winter. You have continue to be wrong on the strength on the cold air all year. That artic blast in January you said would be nothing special, yet NYC was 3 at 10am. You also said NYC would not get to a single digit low at the end February wrong!

I was wrong about the end of Feb, yes. To be fair, I never said the cold outbreak at the end of Jan would be "nothing special". I was ranting about the absurd histrionics coming from the media as if it was the end of the world. That being said, I don't think the strength of this winter changes the fact that the immediate NYC metro area is technically in the northern fringes of a subtropical climate zone. No one month for any NYC station averages below 32F. We have short, moderately cold winters and hot, humid summers. The proximity to the ocean + the urban heat island effects make the climate much more moderate than places immediately to the north or west.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...