Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,862
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    Malmax64
    Newest Member
    Malmax64
    Joined

March 25th Storm: Debacle or Climo Defier? Discussion and Obs II


stormtracker

Recommended Posts

The models were still often too snowy even without snow maps. These anomalous events are always going to be hard if you think about it. It's mostly the people who never make forecasts who get annoyed with forecasts that aren't perfect.

 

I don't know the first thing about forecastig (or really all that much about weather), so I couldn't put out a forecast worth a doggie diamond.

 

But I think I know enough to say that it'd be a pretty tough forecast to make this time of the year.  And in thinking more about it, I suppose I can see zwyts's argument that a discussion of the general verifications wouldn't be too terribly helpful.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 889
  • Created
  • Last Reply

The models were still often too snowy even without snow maps. These anomalous events are always going to be hard if you think about it. It's mostly the people who never make forecasts who get annoyed with forecasts that aren't perfect.

 

"Nailing" ones like this are part luck. I don't care how much experience someone has.. Give any experienced met this setup this time of year ten times in a row and see what their batting average is. 500 at best. 

 

I felt good about 1-3 from 95 west and I busted low but who cares. We got some really good rates over a relatively small geographic area at the perfect time on morning. We got  lucky. If the best rates held off for 3 hours then chop totals in half or worse. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Is that really the policy?...I'm not sure all airports do that

 

 

No, the way its supposed to be measured is you take the max depth in that 6 hour period. You aren't supposed to wait for it to compact and report that at obs time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"Nailing" ones like this are part luck. I don't care how much experience someone has.. Give any experienced met this setup this time of year ten times in a row and see what their batting average is. 500 at best. 

 

I felt good about 1-3 from 95 west and I busted low but who cares. We got some really good rates over a relatively small geographic area at the perfect time on morning. We got  lucky. If the best rates held off for 3 hours then chop totals in half or worse. 

 

 

Good thing Wes stayed out of this one.  No reason to blemish a nearly prfect record. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

"Nailing" ones like this are part luck. I don't care how much experience someone has.. Give any experienced met this setup this time of year ten times in a row and see what their batting average is. 500 at best. 

 

I felt good about 1-3 from 95 west and I busted low but who cares. We got some really good rates over a relatively small geographic area at the perfect time on morning. We got  lucky. If the best rates held off for 3 hours then chop totals in half or worse. 

Bust on March 6th and anti-bust on March 25th.  Everyone was gunshy after that epic bust.  Understandably so.  I think telling folks 1-3" was the safest thing, but it was certainly a low confidence forecast no matter what.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Good thing Wes stayed out of this one.  No reason to blemish a nearly prfect record. ;)

For the sake of objectivity he did say yesterday morning that it would not be much, maybe a few inches in the suburbs. Even the greatest can be wrong once in a while. Forecasting is almost as tough as hitting a baseball and the greatest hit 300.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Bust on March 6th and anti-bust on March 25th.  Everyone was gunshy after that epic bust.  Understandably so.  I think telling folks 1-3" was the safest thing, but it was certainly a <b>low confidence forecast</b> no matter what.  

And this, to me, is NWS's biggest failing, at least here at AKQ where I read the AFDs on a semi-regular basis.. They are either unable or unwilling to discuss uncertainties and confidence levels and competing scenarios in AFDs. They're discussions. It's okay if they're longer than normal when you're not sure. But give me both sides of the coin. Don't say "it's gonna rain, buuuuuutttt.... we're really not sure"...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...