Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,608
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    NH8550
    Newest Member
    NH8550
    Joined

March Med/Long Range Disco


WinterWxLuvr

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 2.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Where do you think the cfs2 predicted anomalies come from?  The cfs2 is constantly running a dynamic model out in time (monthly, or 9 monthly), specifically an atmospheric model (GFS-based) coupled to an interactive ocean model, at low resolution (T126, half the GEFS resolution), to generate the weekly/monthly/seasonal anomaly forecasts. 

 

 

I'm not going to turn this into a political discussion, but I'll stand by what I said.  There's not one single reasonable reason to try and predict weather 9 months in advance.  If someone wants to invest private money into that endeavor, go for it.  As for the CFS2, my opinion of it is that it is totally useless.  Sorry.  This isn't some personal attack on you.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not going to turn this into a political discussion, but I'll stand by what I said.  There's not one single reasonable reason to try and predict weather 9 months in advance.  If someone wants to invest private money into that endeavor, go for it.  As for the CFS2, my opinion of it is that it is totally useless.  Sorry.  This isn't some personal attack on you.

 

Long range prediction has a lot of utility and value...over time, the accuracy and technology will improve....can't get there without doing it with today's available tools.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Long range prediction has a lot of utility and value...over time, the accuracy and technology will improve....can't get there without doing it with today's available tools.

 

OK, I'll play.  How do I benefit from knowing that next November will be within 0.5 degrees of normal?  What tangible effect does this knowledge have on my day to day life?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OK, I'll play.  How do I benefit from knowing that next November will be within 0.5 degrees of normal?  What tangible effect does this knowledge have on my day to day life?

 

dtk and other SMEs can answer that question better...IMO, it's not about being precise to a degree, but more so about general tendencies and trends in the expected weather and climate....that is material and useful information for a range of constituencies, including agriculture, the energy industry, general commerce and business, government, etc, etc.

 

Perhaps your expectations are off in regards to the relative level of metric accuracy of such long range products

Link to comment
Share on other sites

dtk and other SMEs can answer that question better...IMO, it's not about being precise to a degree, but more so about general tendencies and trends in the expected weather and climate....that is material and useful information for a range of constituencies, including agriculture, the energy industry, general commerce and business, government, etc, etc.

 

Perhaps your expectations are off in regards to the relative level of metric accuracy of such long range products

Well, I'll wait for those specifics, but while I'm waiting I'll stick with the opinion that we need to limit the focus, realize that even if an objective is desirable the means are simply not there to do it, and, with a focus on the weather aspect of this, if a forecasting tool can be developed that can give us a good idea of exactly what to expect within a 3-5 day period, that will benefit more people in more ways than some of these other uses of people and money ever will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Man, we don't have many wanting to talk do we?

 

Euro, GFS, NAM all show the chance for snow Mon morning.  Euro, GFS show a really cold week next week, with the possibility of storminess.  Does every map have to show 8-12 before discussion can begin?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Man, we don't have many wanting to talk do we?

 

Euro, GFS, NAM all show the chance for snow Mon morning.  Euro, GFS show a really cold week next week, with the possibility of storminess.  Does every map have to show 8-12 before discussion can begin?

yes. We have not gotten a normal 4-8 inch snowstorm since the 1990;s Its either MECS/HECS or car topper

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Man, we don't have many wanting to talk do we?

 

Euro, GFS, NAM all show the chance for snow Mon morning.  Euro, GFS show a really cold week next week, with the possibility of storminess.  Does every map have to show 8-12 before discussion can begin?

 

most people probably dont have that realistic a shot for much.. tho you could certainly get ground whitening or a few inches with the first sys

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Man, we don't have many wanting to talk do we?

 

Euro, GFS, NAM all show the chance for snow Mon morning.  Euro, GFS show a really cold week next week, with the possibility of storminess.  Does every map have to show 8-12 before discussion can begin?

You got me bud, and that's all you need.   Mon morning looks good for you, not so much for the cityfolk.    Next week is the group's time.    Let's just sit back and bide our time as the discussion grows...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Man, we don't have many wanting to talk do we?

 

Euro, GFS, NAM all show the chance for snow Mon morning.  Euro, GFS show a really cold week next week, with the possibility of storminess.  Does every map have to show 8-12 before discussion can begin?

I don't say much because not that much to say, but I am here with the "glass is half full" mindset. Monday looks ok for you, but don't think much happening east of you snow wise.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm all in.  What's new this winter?  I'm like a 16 pound large mouth bass that has been caught and released about 12 times this winter, but I can't resist that same lure waving in front of my face yet again.  Players on the table for a rare late march big time storm.   LOL

Link to comment
Share on other sites

most people probably dont have that realistic a shot for much.. tho you could certainly get ground whitening or a few inches with the first sys

Ji's right.  Throw out the "couple inches" idea.  We don't get those anymore.  It's either cartoppers or HECS.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Well my thoughts weren't leaning toward actually trying to forecast something.  It's more, "the models give it a chance of happening".  The Euro for Monday morning is particularly interesting to me, and not just for my area.  It's pretty cold, and decent precip is flirting with the area.  If it could get that in here a bit quicker, we might all get a little snow.

 

And next week looks wild.  At this point it looks like anything could happen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...