Jump to content
  • Member Statistics

    17,608
    Total Members
    7,904
    Most Online
    NH8550
    Newest Member
    NH8550
    Joined

December Obs and Banter


WinterWxLuvr

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

responding here as not to clutter the other thread..

I certainly overstated things by saying I'd be stunned if it changed as I didn't expect there to be no changes but didn't see any chance of the low going to our south and east enough for a snowstorm. I still think that is unlikely as the most likely track is still some type of miller b solution. I guess you'll consider my comments equivocated. I certainly did not see the storm coming as far east as it look like it will but still think the odds are that the storm track west of us which keeps most of us from getting a major winter storm. Could we get the latter, sure as I noted in my article. I guess part of the problem with communicating between us is that some always see snow chances (I'm not saying you) pretty much every storm and I probably have reacted too strongly to that. Anyway, congrats to you and Bob.

It's kinda silly that people who 'see' a storm 2-3+ weeks or more out then have it 'verify' actually think they did anything. The whole thing has become grating over recent years more than ever. I don't remember so many "I saw this and did that great" as we hear all the time lately. There's no coincidence that you're one of the best forecasters and also humble/cautious.

I think at some point everyone needs to step back and re-think how the long range is examined. It's one thing to try to find a pattern.. but storm specific talk so far in advance is largely BS hopecasting and should be called out as such IMO. It does no one a service to think that they can nail things down in fantasy range just because a broken clock is right every now and then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree totally ian and I take little credit other than stirring up a lot of extra analysis which is fun anyway. All I ever said is that it appeared to be a window for our first legit threat. Nothing more than that. And I got lucky. I'm not doing it again because I'm too modest for the whole experience.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I agree totally ian and I take little credit other than stirring up a lot of extra analysis which is fun anyway. All I ever said is that it appeared to be a window for our first legit threat. Nothing more than that. And I got lucky. I'm not doing it again because I'm too modest for the whole experience.

I think you're smart enough to know you can't make a specific forecast from range. I'm not sure about a lot of other posters though. Plus, not to detract from your findings, but I think a number of people were "into" late month as a possibility for better.. Part of my reason saying naming storms after posters etc is stupid is we all spend so much time focusing on that the conversation becomes stupid.

It's also possible I've just lost interest in a lot of the talk.. I can look at a model without needing to see someone post a :o about a panel as their description... or even other small details. I don't need to make a lot of posts telling people that I'm great.. or read 'em from others. Hopefully it doesn't all drive away good forecasters who aren't going to go out on a weenie limb from 10-15 days out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I gotcha Ian. I do think our subforum is really really good. I've browsed the others like many. I think the coolest thing is that when things get interesting the vast majority of the posts in the pinned thread are analysis based. And some really good analysis even from armchair folks. We don't have the prolific clutter nearly as bad as some other areas. I prob have a much higher tolerance though. I'm still pretty new around here compared to many.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Snow flurries have been flying all day...occasionally it gets squally with reduced visibility. The wind is brutal though. The roads have been wet for the most part but are now getting snow covered and icy where the treatment is wearing off. Temperature has been slowly falling, now down to 27 and the windchill is getting into the teens. Overall it's been quite a wintery day.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think you're smart enough to know you can't make a specific forecast from range. I'm not sure about a lot of other posters though. Plus, not to detract from your findings, but I think a number of people were "into" late month as a possibility for better.. Part of my reason saying naming storms after posters etc is stupid is we all spend so much time focusing on that the conversation becomes stupid.

It's also possible I've just lost interest in a lot of the talk.. I can look at a model without needing to see someone post a :o about a panel as their description... or even other small details. I don't need to make a lot of posts telling people that I'm great.. or read 'em from others. Hopefully it doesn't all drive away good forecasters who aren't going to go out on a weenie limb from 10-15 days out.

I haven't seen any chest-thumping in our forum at all...weeniesm has increased, but haven't seen any self congratulatory back patting

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I gotcha Ian. I do think our subforum is really really good. I've browsed the others like many. I think the coolest thing is that when things get interesting the vast majority of the posts in the pinned thread are analysis based. And some really good analysis even from armchair folks. We don't have the prolific clutter nearly as bad as some other areas. I prob have a much higher tolerance though. I'm still pretty new around here compared to many.

you deserve some credit for this storm....I'm not sure who Ian is referring to in this forum...we have all been modest and humble...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I gotcha Ian. I do think our subforum is really really good. I've browsed the others like many. I think the coolest thing is that when things get interesting the vast majority of the posts in the pinned thread are analysis based. And some really good analysis even from armchair folks. We don't have the prolific clutter nearly as bad as some other areas. I prob have a much higher tolerance though. I'm still pretty new around here compared to many.

Our forum is pretty good.. it is also apparent it's been a while since we've had a good snow.. many people are being a little extra lenient on the general game around here when it comes to getting snow. I'm probably partly burnt out and have tended to not care as much about snow talk over the last few years. But I've also had a number of red taggers voice their opinions lately... not necessarily the thoughts I'd hope to hear about the direction of things.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ian, as an obsessive forum reader, and pretty nothing contributor, I have enjoyed the chatter during the slow period from Matt and Bob and a few others, it was a decent set of reads and even some stuff to chew over. Wes too. I guess I am confused about who was chest-thumping or who even truly "called" a storm. At best, a few said this looked like a good window where something frozen might fall. That's not different from stuff others have done in the past looking ahead at patterns. its not different from what HM does, I don't think.

I guess I am confused as to the criticism and what you would like to be different....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ian, as an obsessive forum reader, and pretty nothing contributor, I have enjoyed the chatter during the slow period from Matt and Bob and a few others, it was a decent set of reads and even some stuff to chew over. Wes too. I guess I am confused about who was chest-thumping or who even truly "called" a storm. At best, a few said this looked like a good window where something frozen might fall. That's not different from stuff others have done in the past looking ahead at patterns. its not different from what HM does, I don't think.

I guess I am confused as to the criticism and what you would like to be different....

nobody has self-congratulated or chest-thumped...If anything I locked in way too early to a far west/rain solution....this storm was a good reminder about locking into anything too quickly...This is a humble forum, mainly because our titular leader Wes is a humble forecaster...he sets the tone....other than some minutia and recent weenieism this is a good forum

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

×
×
  • Create New...