It's good to see you board-side! We're often on the same wavelength so not surprised we both raised an eyebrow at how statements were handled yesterday. Sure, it was and is an uncertain forecast regarding total accumulations, but I think the goalposts are actually rather narrow for sensible weather impacts. Significant accumulations of frozen precip have been a near-lock for a few days. That's more than we can say about many systems, even in the past few seasons.
I honestly haven't had much time to delve into the model data, so I'm in more of a wait-and-see mode than usual. Given the paradox of overrunning (stronger WAA = more precip but quicker mixing), I don't have huge expectations for today. It's especially discouraging to hear reports of sleet already (and even fzra in Newburgh, per my dad). You can cool the melting layer back down with strong enough lift, but only so much, and only for so long before the warm flow wins out. I'll finally have a chance this afternoon to pore over the forecast soundings and cross-sections for the potential deformation snows tomorrow, but as of now I think that's going to be the bigger story.
Just at a cursory look, the banding on the hi-res RGEM is really impressive, and it's not terribly far off from the NAM and extended HRRR in terms of low and CCB placement. This would get most of us to double-digit totals even if today fails to deliver.