Ill probably go B+ but I dont like grading before April. Im sitting at 39.8" of snow, so snowfall itself very average overall. A hot start but a shitty February and so far a non-existent March. However despite very mundane weather since mid-February, that does not take away the fact that the winter featured well below avg temps and well above avg snowcover. A huge majority of Decemer to mid-February featured a thick glittery blanket of snow, constant flakes, and crisp cold winter air. The "early exit" sucks, but doesnt take away the early arrival either. Cant recall a winter when deep winter set in so early. We had just two brief meltoffs between Thanksgiving & mid-Feb (Christmas & 2nd week of Jan), surprised you melted in early Dec.