for us amateurs, the model parade is largely the best medium to base our guesses off of. Sprinkle in telies/ base state (ENSO), knowledge of climo and whatever other tools us rookies use. It IS the fun on a weather disco board IMO. We get to throw our thoughts in without any bashing from public....just from fellow weather geeks. Like you, I'm totally cool w/ that.
While we should have payed better attention to northern fringe on this one, the true CTP'rs overperformed as forcing set up north of us, so one persons epic fail, is anothers quiet little victory. Had that forcing been a bit closer, many 3-6 calls may have worked out a bit better.
Thats the fun of this hobby. Figurin that shit out.