I agree with you that it's standard nina climo that we usually get stuck between suppressed cold/dry and warm/wet cutter tracks.
With a moderate but weakening nina, -PDO, and the NAO being projected to avg weakly positive, I still lean towards a below normal snowfall this winter.
But there are a couple of X factors that didn't exist on previous analogs - one being that the ATL hurricane season has been uncharacteristically quiet, and two being the H2O vapor eruption with undetermined effects on the stratosphere (i.e. there is a long chain of "ifs" that must come true to get -AO from a NH strat warming as a result).
Again, leaning BN snowfall, but leaving the door open to a couple of surprises.