In January 1965 I headed out to ice fish on our 50-acre lake, the rain having quickly plunged thru ZR to IP, 30s/20s/upper teens, pelting we idiot anglers all day. Next morning the temp was rising and the precip ZR, ending late aft and leaving 1/2" ice atop 2.5" IP. Having forgotten my creepers, I had a wicked nasty time getting off the lake - couldn't even stomp a dent into that stuff. Next day kids donned ice skates and cruised thru their yards.
NYC stats:
1/23 47 24 0.64" 1.0" max at 12:01 AM
1/24 32 24 0.51" 2.2" max at 11:59 PM