Not many October historical tracks like the eps there.. Closest I found was Cat 1 Unnamed Oct 24, 1859 to Oct 29, 1859. Cat 2 Unnamed Oct 08, 1888 to Oct 12, 1888 looks similar too.
Assuming my search is correct there hasn't been a hurricane that originated in the Gulf and struck within 150mi of Sarasota since that storm in 1888. Not implying any forecast with that tidbit, just find it interesting.