I hardly even remember PD2. I'd suspect it's because I was working (bartender) and drunk pretty much the whole time because barely any other restaurants were open for a few days afterwards.
I got stuck in Wilkes-Barre, PA during '96. We got about 20" up there, while my hometown in Jersey got 33".
December 18-19 was an awesome storm, but its 22" was almost dwarfed by the 27" from Feb 5-6. I only got 8-9" from Feb 10, but the morning blizzard band was pretty sick.
No doubt, though, that Dec 18-19 was in my top 5 all time. Easy.