Would they? I could see that N and W but some on here have said that ratios would not reach that level from NYC and east due to strong winds and that 10:1 was more likely.
It gives NYC about an inch and that's only at 12z when before it gave nothing. Most other models give 6-8. Which forecast do you think is most likely given what we have seen so far?
Dutchess county and me north of 84 may actually only get 2-4, that is possible, but places like Rockland that you mentioned should get 6 or possibly more.
That may be true but 4-8 or 6-8 is still a good storm if that is the end result. You make it seem like it's going to be 1-3. I wouldn't too much trust in the GFS.