Long post:
It does seem like this blocking pattern isn't perpetually 10 days away on the ensembles, as both the EPS and the GEFS bring out the purple coloring at hr 96. Of course, it isn't immediately in an ideal location. I wonder if there's much precedent for blocks moving north instead of retrograding west as I've often heard about. Looking at both the american and the european suites, it does seem like maybe the path is NW, so some sort of a compromise. To my eye, it looks like this miller B Jan 4th storm bombs out near Newfoundland and sort of runs into those higher heights like a battering ram and pushes it NW? I'm not a scientist, so I don't know much of the physical processes involved.
Wisdom says that our best chances occur at the formation and dissolution of these blocks, with the best chance at the dissolution, as some modified cP air has usually been dislodged south at that point, which is what I believe happened with our 12/16-17 storm? So, this wisdom leads me to assign Jan 8-9 and some time mid-late January (maybe the 18th-20th) as the most legitimate threats. I'd be interested to see if this verifies.
We also seem to be southern stream dominated at first, with northern stream chances improving if we somehow get some PAC ridging going on mid-month. I think most in NE would agree, with the exception of some far SW Connecticut people, that Manitoba Maulers forced under a block is a much preferable synopsis to a southern stream event.
Anyways, someone correct me if I'm wrong, but we haven't had actual sustained -NAO conditions in January for quite some time.
According to this table I snipped off of CPC's site, we haven't averaged a neg NAO in Jan since 2010 and 2011, and obviously, we know the history of those winters. Many of us prefer one of those to the other, but the point remains that we haven't seen this kind of stuff in a while. I wonder if we can actually pull it off.
edit: I can recall 2016, before the blizzard, having something like -4 SDs AO conditions, so I'd assume there was some extended period of -NAO there as well