-
Posts
1,572 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Blogs
Forums
American Weather
Media Demo
Store
Gallery
Everything posted by Henry's Weather
-
This is a dumb tweet
-
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
Pulling for ya -
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
Valid point, but if you had used 1950-2011 data, this would be all red. -
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
Right, it’s not that people can’t want outcomes. It’s that logical discourse allows us to find which outcomes are actually most likely. Argumentation needs to have primary salience for why someone thinks something is going to happen. Otherwise, the scientific enterprise is not happening, for better or for worse. God, this conversation makes me want to start a blog a la @weatherwizand others. Just some sort of objective metric. -
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
From an intellectual basis, sure, but calling a winter storm window and receiving a KU during that window must also be immensely gratifying. But sure, ideally you would nest the correct sensible weather prediction in an accurate assessment of the long-wave pattern and its flux -
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
I personally think it’s better to make predictions and see how they fare against reality than to never make predictions because of the inevitability of being wrong in some way. I think more is learned from trial and error than no trial at all. I think it’s a trait related to psychological conscientiousness, if I had to speculate -
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
There’s hardly any satisfaction in predicting an index mean, when it doesn’t pertain to sensible weather outcomes -
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
There is so much that gets lost along the chain of large-scale synoptic facts -> small-scale sensible weather impact. I think what is keeping you making these outcome-specific forecasts is the high from predicting the specifics pretty accurately for 2014-15, 2015-16, and 2017-18. That sort of intellectual satisfaction is highly appealing. -
It was a Flop... February 2024 Disco. Thread
Henry's Weather replied to Prismshine Productions's topic in New England
People hate on pessimists not because they’re wrong (since a lack of significant wintry weather is always more likely than significant wintry weather), but because their bias is clear, and because it is also clear that they relish the negative response from the hopefuls. Two facts: people who post here hope for snow. And, snow events are becoming more infrequent. Therefore, performative, inert pessimism is more accurate than naive optimism over the long run. However, since the realities I mentioned above are already implicit in this endeavor, dispositional pessimists, though they end up being right more often, are “raining on this particular parade”. To extend the analogy, you don’t have to go to a Red Sox bar with a Yankees cap on, even if the reality of the game is independent of what clothes you wear. The truth is: recreational weather discussion is motivated by hope for certain outcomes, and doomers will frequently “wear the hat” of the objective observer to rile up the subjective hopefuls, but often these people, like @jbenedet, make woeful predictions to serve the God of pessimism. The motivation becomes to frustrate the hopefuls, not to make correct forecasts. It is possible to be a pessimist and also hold yourself to an objective standard of truth. The same is true for optimists or hopefuls. The reason why @40/70 Benchmark gets more respect on this board than someone like Omega or the Pope is because he releases outlooks and then grades himself on how accurate they were, even if it is clear that he wants a specific outcome. -
2015 vibes here