Been reading for the last four days. I'm now convinced the closest analogue here is January 2010, roughly 2-3 weeks before Snowmageddon.
People forget the number of storms we had in '09-'10. We got quite a bit of snow outside the three blizzards. This analogue isn't on Ray's storm archive because it didn't really reach NJ. But it was depicted by several models to blast NC and VA, leaving DC with a few Advisory-level inches--and while the former came true, the moisture shield spread much farther north than anticipated. I was working at SUBWAY in College Park as a senior in college, and I remember getting snowed in at work. We easily got 6-8" that day.
The track and setup are very similar here. I'm betting the precip shield ends up blooming norther than depicted now, with a wider max stripe.