There's a band I adore, and have seen 17 times now going back to 2017. They are a rock band. They're late 30s early 40s, so grew up on all of that 90s rock. They do a number of covers of songs like this. Only thing that makes them less palatable to a larger audience, is they jam. Their originals sound like they belong in the 90s, but they jam them out. Not for everyone.
They just did 3 nights at Soundcheck Studios in Pembroke, but tour often in the northeast.
Spafford is their name.
https://www.spafford.net/listen.html
https://www.youtube.com/@SpaffordMusic/videos