2000-01 is obviously an analog that will be floated around with it being one of the limited number of examples of a 3rd year Nina. Everybody remembers that December, which was pretty historic in some areas, but another thing I remember is how quickly that winter pretty much shut off in my area once January 2001 arrived. I went back and looked at some stats to refresh my memory about how bad things got. Chicago only received 8.2" between Jan-Apr 2001 (4.0" of which came in a March storm), which is the 4th lowest amount of snow on record during that time, and the lowest since 1949. And it's not like it became warm overall or excessively dry. Just horrid timing with it usually not being cold enough at the right time.
When that crazy December was happening, I wondered if we were on the way to an incredibly snowy winter. I loved getting so much snow that month, but it just quickly flamed out after such a remarkable start.