Haha, it definitely is a matter of the order of what the models show as to what everyone's expectations are. I also think I'm just starved for something significant. It's been nine years. Half a foot is fine, but 6 inches or less is basically all I've had for 9 years (that's what she said).
The GFS is just a stronger and much longer storm than the Euro. Which is right? Probably the Euro since it's the better model, more realistic scenario, and generally matches the other models.